2017 Fantasy Projection Evaluation

Fantasy-relevant accuracy for 2017, limited to the top 250 players by FantasyPros's preseason ADP aggregate. Limited to 5x5 categories, with playing time (PA/BF) split out from rates.

Summary

Batting

System PA HR SB R RBI AVG
ATC
Aggregate
Depth Charts
Marcel
OOPSY
Razzball
Steamer
The BAT
The BAT X
ZiPS

Pitching

System BF SO W SV ERA WHIP
ATC
Aggregate
Depth Charts
Marcel
OOPSY
Razzball
Steamer
The BAT
The BAT X
ZiPS

Batting Projection Accuracy

Plate Appearances (PA)

Everybody Missed for Plate Appearances (PA)

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Adam Eaton 107
658
(551.4)
622
(515.0)
651
(543.7)
666
(559.0)
Yasmany Tomás 180
499
(318.9)
530
(350.0)
474
(293.8)
524
(344.0)
Ian Desmond 373
604
(231.2)
597
(224.0)
569
(196.4)
639
(266.0)
Giancarlo Stanton 692
499
(193.4)
470
(222.0)
513
(178.7)
484
(208.0)
Devon Travis 197
490
(293.5)
448
(251.0)
510
(313.0)
471
(274.0)
Yoenis Cespedes 321
590
(269.2)
534
(213.0)
584
(263.5)
596
(275.0)
Troy Tulowitzki 260
488
(227.9)
519
(259.0)
495
(234.9)
481
(221.0)
Jason Kipnis 373
612
(238.9)
606
(233.0)
594
(220.8)
630
(257.0)
Adrián González 252
575
(323.3)
570
(318.0)
574
(321.6)
577
(325.0)

Individual Misses for Plate Appearances (PA)

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Greg Bird 435 170 265.4
2 Yoán Moncada 467 231 236.2
3 Starling Marte 572 339 233.5
4 Aledmys Díaz 533 301 231.9
5 Stephen Piscotty 619 401 218.2
6 Joc Pederson 532 323 209.1
7 Gregory Polanco 607 411 195.8
8 Addison Russell 580 385 194.6
9 Stephen Vogt 485 303 182.2
10 Adrian Beltré 567 389 178.2

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Eric Thames 100 551 451.0
2 Andrew Benintendi 268 658 390.0
3 Alex Bregman 320 626 306.0
4 Mike Moustakas 318 598 280.0
5 Dansby Swanson 282 551 269.0
6 Dee Strange-Gordon 438 695 257.0
7 Hunter Renfroe 223 479 256.0
8 Ryon Healy 350 605 255.0
9 Kyle Schwarber 237 486 249.0
10 Stephen Vogt 511 303 208.0

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Greg Bird 474 170 303.9
2 Aledmys Díaz 555 301 253.8
3 Starling Marte 564 339 225.0
4 Stephen Piscotty 613 401 212.4
5 Jonathan Villar 642 436 205.7
6 Joc Pederson 524 323 201.3
7 Stephen Vogt 503 303 200.4
8 Gregory Polanco 602 411 190.6
9 Trea Turner 635 447 187.8
10 Adrian Beltré 572 389 183.5

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Yoán Moncada 650 231 419.0
2 Starling Marte 581 339 242.0
3 Greg Bird 397 170 227.0
4 Stephen Piscotty 625 401 224.0
5 Mike Moustakas 381 598 217.0
6 Joc Pederson 540 323 217.0
7 Addison Russell 601 385 216.0
8 Aledmys Díaz 511 301 210.0
9 Carlos Correa 682 481 201.0
10 Gregory Polanco 612 411 201.0

Most Unique Misses for Plate Appearances (PA)

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Eric Thames 100 509 551 451.0 41.9 409.1
2 Andrew Benintendi 268 531 658 390.0 127.3 262.7
3 Alex Bregman 320 571 626 306.0 55.4 250.6
4 Ryon Healy 350 590 605 255.0 15.0 240.0
5 Kyle Schwarber 237 500 486 249.0 14.0 235.0
6 Dansby Swanson 282 587 551 269.0 36.1 232.9
7 Gary Sánchez 322 510 525 203.0 15.2 187.8
8 Dee Strange-Gordon 438 614 695 257.0 80.5 176.5
9 Tim Anderson 428 609 606 178.0 2.8 175.2
10 Hunter Renfroe 223 564 479 256.0 85.0 171.0

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Rajai Davis 546 407 366 180.4 40.7 139.7
2 AJ Pollock 576 510 466 110.0 44.5 65.5
3 Kevin Kiermaier 598 550 421 177.5 129.2 48.2
4 Jay Bruce 488 536 617 129.0 81.5 47.5
5 Elvis Andrus 547 594 689 142.0 95.0 47.0
6 Logan Forsythe 588 543 439 149.1 103.5 45.5
7 Kyle Schwarber 539 500 486 53.0 14.0 39.0
8 Matt Holliday 485 407 427 58.4 19.8 38.6
9 Greg Bird 474 435 170 303.9 265.4 38.4
10 Mookie Betts 643 676 712 69.4 35.7 33.7

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Yoán Moncada 650 467 231 419.0 236.2 182.8
2 Mike Moustakas 381 472 598 217.0 125.9 91.1
3 Matt Holliday 329 407 427 98.0 19.8 78.2
4 Jarrod Dyson 303 367 390 87.0 23.4 63.6
5 Rajai Davis 267 407 366 99.0 40.7 58.3
6 Justin Turner 461 517 543 82.0 26.1 55.9
7 José Peraza 593 545 518 75.0 27.1 47.9
8 Evan Gattis 508 461 325 183.0 135.6 47.4
9 Brandon Drury 581 535 480 101.0 54.8 46.2
10 Eduardo Núñez 406 443 491 85.0 47.9 37.1

Home Run Rate

Everybody Missed for Home Run Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Khris Davis 0.1138
0.0782
(19.4)
0.0829
(15.2)
0.0793
(18.3)
0.0771
(20.6)
J.D. Martinez 0.1461
0.0725
(33.2)
0.0698
(33.7)
0.0675
(35.3)
0.0775
(31.1)
Mark Trumbo 0.0560
0.0846
(20.8)
0.0756
(16.3)
0.0837
(20.6)
0.0856
(20.9)
Albert Pujols 0.0456
0.0599
(12.8)
0.0588
(13.2)
0.0602
(13.3)
0.0597
(12.2)
Carlos González 0.0392
0.0715
(20.3)
0.0640
(17.3)
0.0683
(19.0)
0.0747
(21.6)
José Ramírez 0.0557
0.0210
(18.6)
0.0225
(16.5)
0.0222
(17.4)
0.0198
(19.8)
Francisco Lindor 0.0583
0.0307
(15.8)
0.0325
(13.3)
0.0295
(16.2)
0.0318
(15.5)
Miguel Cabrera 0.0442
0.0671
(15.2)
0.0604
(12.5)
0.0688
(16.4)
0.0655
(14.0)
Marcell Ozuna 0.0786
0.0479
(16.9)
0.0453
(17.5)
0.0488
(15.8)
0.0469
(18.0)
Mike Moustakas 0.0814
0.0484
(16.3)
0.0451
(17.2)
0.0527
(13.3)
0.0441
(19.3)
Josh Donaldson 0.1078
0.0748
(13.5)
0.0709
(14.6)
0.0726
(14.3)
0.0771
(12.7)
Jonathan Lucroy 0.0160
0.0372
(13.0)
0.0394
(14.9)
0.0380
(13.7)
0.0365
(12.3)
José Bautista 0.0542
0.0792
(21.1)
0.0733
(18.2)
0.0773
(20.2)
0.0811
(21.9)
Evan Longoria 0.0388
0.0611
(19.0)
0.0531
(14.8)
0.0578
(17.3)
0.0644
(20.8)

Individual Misses for Home Run Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Charlie Blackmon 0.0462 0.0718 14.4
2 Jay Bruce 0.0582 0.0859 13.5
3 Ian Desmond 0.0554 0.0271 12.7
4 Kris Bryant 0.0808 0.0679 12.4
5 Mike Napoli 0.0779 0.1090 12.3
6 Carlos Santana 0.0606 0.0480 12.2

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Giancarlo Stanton 0.0944 0.1350 22.9
2 Eric Thames 0.0564 0.1013 20.6
3 Kyle Schwarber 0.0662 0.1103 17.8
4 Mike Napoli 0.0687 0.1090 15.9
5 Dansby Swanson 0.0357 0.0161 14.9
6 Charlie Blackmon 0.0455 0.0718 13.7

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Charlie Blackmon 0.0408 0.0718 17.8
2 Mike Napoli 0.0756 0.1090 13.1
3 Kyle Schwarber 0.0771 0.1103 13.0
4 Ian Desmond 0.0541 0.0271 12.5
5 Hunter Renfroe 0.0526 0.0850 12.4
6 Xander Bogaerts 0.0349 0.0219 12.3

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Jay Bruce 0.0549 0.0859 16.0
2 Chris Davis 0.1223 0.0981 15.3
3 Kris Bryant 0.0829 0.0679 13.4
4 Ian Desmond 0.0567 0.0271 12.9
5 Elvis Andrus 0.0138 0.0366 12.2
6 Carlos Santana 0.0611 0.0480 12.1

Most Unique Misses for Home Run Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Eric Thames 0.0564 0.0826 0.1013 20.6 7.1 13.5
2 Giancarlo Stanton 0.0944 0.1126 0.1350 22.9 11.5 11.4
3 Kyle Schwarber 0.0662 0.0911 0.1103 17.8 6.5 11.2
4 Trea Turner 0.0468 0.0327 0.0330 9.5 2.4 7.1
5 Wil Myers 0.0499 0.0608 0.0761 12.2 6.2 6.0
6 Yasiel Puig 0.0408 0.0522 0.0693 12.0 6.5 5.5
7 Brandon Drury 0.0414 0.0317 0.0378 5.3 0.1 5.2
8 Javier Báez 0.0438 0.0556 0.0691 9.0 3.9 5.1
9 Matt Holliday 0.0458 0.0592 0.0720 8.0 3.0 5.0
10 José Peraza 0.0228 0.0152 0.0119 9.5 4.7 4.8

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Kyle Schwarber 0.0771 0.0911 0.1103 13.0 6.5 6.5
2 Charlie Blackmon 0.0408 0.0462 0.0718 17.8 14.4 3.4
3 Keon Broxton 0.0503 0.0575 0.0830 12.1 9.1 3.0
4 Brian Dozier 0.0585 0.0631 0.0711 4.4 1.6 2.8
5 Melky Cabrera 0.0285 0.0253 0.0307 2.8 0.2 2.6
6 Eric Hosmer 0.0476 0.0437 0.0499 2.8 0.3 2.5
7 Mookie Betts 0.0474 0.0449 0.0433 7.5 5.2 2.3
8 Hanley Ramirez 0.0602 0.0569 0.0605 3.4 1.2 2.2
9 J.D. Martinez 0.0675 0.0725 0.1461 35.3 33.2 2.1
10 George Springer 0.0665 0.0703 0.0767 2.4 0.4 2.0

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Trevor Story 0.0818 0.0741 0.0767 5.6 1.8 3.9
2 Chris Davis 0.1223 0.1144 0.0981 15.3 11.6 3.8
3 Eric Hosmer 0.0399 0.0437 0.0499 3.3 0.3 3.0
4 Mike Moustakas 0.0441 0.0484 0.0814 19.3 16.3 3.0
5 Nelson Cruz 0.0940 0.0889 0.0922 4.4 1.6 2.8
6 Jay Bruce 0.0549 0.0582 0.0859 16.0 13.5 2.5
7 Melky Cabrera 0.0221 0.0253 0.0307 2.3 0.2 2.1
8 Nolan Arenado 0.0760 0.0725 0.0728 5.6 3.7 1.9
9 Corey Seager 0.0427 0.0451 0.0535 3.5 1.6 1.9
10 Yasmani Grandal 0.0785 0.0741 0.0705 6.3 4.5 1.8

Stolen Base Rate

Everybody Missed for Stolen Base Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Yasiel Puig 0.1049
0.0516
(33.8)
0.0561
(31.4)
0.0521
(31.8)
0.0511
(35.9)
Byron Buxton 0.2358
0.1412
(51.4)
0.1169
(63.9)
0.1445
(48.1)
0.1379
(54.7)
Xander Bogaerts 0.0882
0.0538
(25.8)
0.0533
(26.1)
0.0517
(25.1)
0.0559
(26.4)
Todd Frazier 0.0265
0.0924
(34.4)
0.1008
(39.2)
0.0841
(31.5)
0.1007
(37.5)
Alex Bregman 0.1083
0.0606
(33.6)
0.0571
(35.9)
0.0602
(31.9)
0.0611
(35.3)
Rougned Odor 0.1364
0.0948
(31.0)
0.0820
(39.4)
0.0978
(27.0)
0.0916
(35.1)
José Reyes 0.1875
0.1356
(32.5)
0.1474
(26.0)
0.1282
(34.9)
0.1429
(30.2)
Carlos Correa 0.0145
0.0981
(37.3)
0.0850
(30.9)
0.0829
(31.5)
0.1136
(43.3)
Charlie Blackmon 0.0693
0.1443
(49.9)
0.1513
(55.0)
0.1387
(48.2)
0.1500
(51.8)
Yadier Molina 0.0732
0.0217
(31.2)
0.0213
(31.5)
0.0206
(30.1)
0.0229
(32.3)
Rajai Davis 0.3580
0.1457
(79.9)
0.2685
(35.0)
0.2720
(32.5)
0.0000
(134.4)
DJ LeMahieu 0.0280
0.0847
(34.5)
0.0760
(28.5)
0.0697
(26.4)
0.1000
(42.8)
Trea Turner 0.4182
0.2417
(81.6)
0.2526
(76.8)
0.2420
(80.1)
0.2414
(83.1)

Individual Misses for Stolen Base Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Yoán Moncada 0.2058 0.0500 34.6
2 Eric Thames 0.0974 0.0292 34.3
3 Billy Hamilton 0.4374 0.3782 33.6
4 Odúbel Herrera 0.1174 0.0645 26.3
5 Trevor Story 0.1157 0.0625 26.2
6 Jacoby Ellsbury 0.1441 0.2018 26.1
7 Jarrod Dyson 0.3417 0.2692 25.9

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Andrew Benintendi 0.0469 0.1087 44.8
2 Jay Bruce 0.0619 0.0075 29.8
3 Hanley Ramirez 0.0647 0.0077 28.1
4 Jacoby Ellsbury 0.1469 0.2018 25.0
5 Mike Trout 0.0924 0.1350 24.7
6 Mookie Betts 0.1235 0.1503 23.5
7 Dansby Swanson 0.0694 0.0213 23.1

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Eric Thames 0.1016 0.0292 38.3
2 Yoán Moncada 0.2028 0.0500 34.6
3 Jacoby Ellsbury 0.1304 0.2018 30.4
4 George Springer 0.0754 0.0299 26.7
5 Odúbel Herrera 0.1121 0.0645 25.1
6 Bryce Harper 0.0790 0.0274 23.9
7 Jonathan Villar 0.2942 0.2371 23.6

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Billy Hamilton 0.4720 0.3782 53.5
2 Jarrod Dyson 0.3867 0.2692 42.2
3 Yoán Moncada 0.2086 0.0500 34.5
4 Trevor Story 0.1284 0.0625 31.5
5 Eric Thames 0.0926 0.0292 29.9
6 Evan Longoria 0.0071 0.0390 27.8
7 Odúbel Herrera 0.1227 0.0645 27.6

Most Unique Misses for Stolen Base Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Andrew Benintendi 0.0469 0.1000 0.1087 44.8 9.7 35.0
2 Byron Buxton 0.1169 0.1412 0.2358 63.9 51.4 12.5
3 Giancarlo Stanton 0.0439 0.0278 0.0118 17.9 6.8 11.0
4 Tim Anderson 0.0947 0.1495 0.1250 22.1 11.1 11.0
5 Jay Bruce 0.0619 0.0469 0.0075 29.8 20.5 9.2
6 Mookie Betts 0.1235 0.1360 0.1503 23.5 14.5 9.0
7 Ryon Healy 0.0253 0.0103 0.0000 11.6 2.6 9.0
8 Rougned Odor 0.0820 0.0948 0.1364 39.4 31.0 8.4
9 Dansby Swanson 0.0694 0.0557 0.0213 23.1 15.6 7.5
10 Mike Trout 0.0924 0.1065 0.1350 24.7 17.5 7.2

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Dee Strange-Gordon 0.2768 0.2972 0.2927 13.0 1.1 11.9
2 Lorenzo Cain 0.1148 0.1309 0.1390 17.5 9.1 8.4
3 Jonathan Schoop 0.0239 0.0167 0.0062 10.0 3.0 7.0
4 Michael Brantley 0.0604 0.0817 0.1058 18.1 11.3 6.8
5 Kyle Schwarber 0.0462 0.0371 0.0094 16.5 10.5 6.0
6 Mookie Betts 0.1246 0.1360 0.1503 20.4 14.5 5.8
7 Ian Desmond 0.0975 0.1156 0.1471 19.6 14.0 5.6
8 Elvis Andrus 0.1399 0.1510 0.1524 10.7 5.1 5.5
9 Mike Moustakas 0.0237 0.0177 0.0000 12.4 7.0 5.5
10 Matt Carpenter 0.0235 0.0180 0.0110 5.9 0.6 5.4

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Rajai Davis 0.0000 0.1457 0.3580 134.4 79.9 54.5
2 Billy Hamilton 0.4720 0.4374 0.3782 53.5 33.6 19.9
3 Jarrod Dyson 0.3867 0.3417 0.2692 42.2 25.9 16.3
4 Jose Altuve 0.1907 0.1716 0.1569 16.3 5.7 10.6
5 Dee Strange-Gordon 0.3171 0.2972 0.2927 10.6 1.1 9.5
6 Jean Segura 0.1911 0.1726 0.1429 22.1 13.4 8.7
7 DJ LeMahieu 0.1000 0.0847 0.0280 42.8 34.5 8.3
8 Carlos González 0.0560 0.0375 0.0226 12.9 4.7 8.2
9 Javier Báez 0.1416 0.1226 0.0909 21.1 13.0 8.1
10 Nomar Mazara 0.0000 0.0085 0.0136 14.1 6.9 7.2

Run Rate

Everybody Missed for Run Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
J.D. Martinez 0.1738
0.1297
(18.6)
0.1300
(18.9)
0.1323
(16.9)
0.1271
(20.3)
Albert Pujols 0.0833
0.1232
(29.2)
0.1196
(26.3)
0.1259
(31.5)
0.1205
(26.9)
Manny Machado 0.1174
0.1430
(21.8)
0.1372
(17.2)
0.1451
(23.9)
0.1409
(19.8)
Giancarlo Stanton 0.1777
0.1407
(21.5)
0.1298
(29.6)
0.1450
(17.9)
0.1364
(25.1)
José Ramírez 0.1659
0.1200
(25.7)
0.1290
(20.4)
0.1165
(27.4)
0.1234
(24.1)
Carlos Correa 0.1705
0.1283
(17.4)
0.1162
(23.6)
0.1319
(15.2)
0.1246
(19.6)
Miguel Cabrera 0.0945
0.1364
(25.3)
0.1323
(22.7)
0.1475
(31.7)
0.1252
(19.0)
Charlie Blackmon 0.1890
0.1346
(35.0)
0.1436
(29.2)
0.1419
(29.1)
0.1274
(40.9)
Dee Strange-Gordon 0.1640
0.1266
(21.8)
0.1324
(18.4)
0.1180
(27.2)
0.1353
(16.4)
Paul Goldschmidt 0.1759
0.1404
(19.6)
0.1452
(17.0)
0.1395
(19.6)
0.1413
(19.6)
Bryce Harper 0.1931
0.1487
(18.9)
0.1417
(22.8)
0.1507
(17.4)
0.1467
(20.3)
Adrián González 0.0556
0.1145
(16.4)
0.1158
(16.5)
0.1147
(16.7)
0.1144
(16.1)
Elvis Andrus 0.1451
0.1112
(19.2)
0.1145
(17.5)
0.1085
(20.5)
0.1139
(18.0)

Individual Misses for Run Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Jose Altuve 0.1375 0.1692 17.0
2 Gregory Polanco 0.1284 0.0949 16.3
3 Troy Tulowitzki 0.1173 0.0615 16.1
4 Hunter Pence 0.1255 0.1020 15.9
5 George Springer 0.1475 0.1781 15.4
6 Maikel Franco 0.1245 0.1059 15.4
7 Jonathan Lucroy 0.1177 0.0936 14.5

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Jose Altuve 0.1323 0.1692 21.0
2 George Springer 0.1401 0.1781 20.6
3 Hunter Pence 0.1350 0.1020 20.6
4 Troy Tulowitzki 0.1291 0.0615 18.9
5 Jackie Bradley Jr. 0.1364 0.1072 18.6
6 Javier Báez 0.1061 0.1476 18.5
7 Gregory Polanco 0.1318 0.0949 17.3

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Hanley Ramirez 0.1334 0.1049 19.6
2 Victor Martinez 0.1225 0.0874 18.3
3 Dustin Pedroia 0.1319 0.0994 18.3
4 Troy Tulowitzki 0.1244 0.0615 18.1
5 George Springer 0.1441 0.1781 17.0
6 Jonathan Lucroy 0.1217 0.0936 16.9
7 Javier Báez 0.1101 0.1476 15.6

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Hunter Pence 0.1379 0.1020 22.1
2 Wil Myers 0.1481 0.1233 19.5
3 Jose Altuve 0.1351 0.1692 19.2
4 Gregory Polanco 0.1340 0.0949 18.2
5 Maikel Franco 0.1291 0.1059 17.6
6 Kyle Schwarber 0.1670 0.1379 16.7
7 Matt Kemp 0.1281 0.1006 15.2

Most Unique Misses for Run Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Trevor Story 0.1439 0.1249 0.1225 14.7 4.7 10.1
2 Carlos Santana 0.1153 0.1288 0.1349 9.6 0.1 9.5
3 Giancarlo Stanton 0.1298 0.1407 0.1777 29.6 21.5 8.1
4 Jackie Bradley Jr. 0.1364 0.1235 0.1072 18.6 12.1 6.5
5 Tim Anderson 0.1262 0.1146 0.1188 7.6 1.1 6.5
6 Carlos Correa 0.1162 0.1283 0.1705 23.6 17.4 6.3
7 Hunter Renfroe 0.1256 0.1132 0.1065 11.6 6.1 5.5
8 Corey Seager 0.1426 0.1329 0.1387 5.6 0.2 5.4
9 José Abreu 0.1160 0.1230 0.1407 13.2 7.9 5.3
10 George Springer 0.1401 0.1475 0.1781 20.6 15.4 5.2

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Carlos Santana 0.1437 0.1288 0.1349 10.5 0.1 10.4
2 Nick Castellanos 0.1158 0.1061 0.1098 8.6 1.6 7.1
3 Victor Martinez 0.1225 0.1076 0.0874 18.3 11.4 6.9
4 Miguel Cabrera 0.1475 0.1364 0.0945 31.7 25.3 6.4
5 Dee Strange-Gordon 0.1180 0.1266 0.1640 27.2 21.8 5.4
6 Ender Inciarte 0.1144 0.1243 0.1295 5.9 0.6 5.3
7 Hanley Ramirez 0.1334 0.1249 0.1049 19.6 14.4 5.2
8 Nomar Mazara 0.1182 0.1109 0.1039 13.1 8.1 5.0
9 Matt Holliday 0.1274 0.1169 0.1171 7.3 2.5 4.9
10 Ian Kinsler 0.1254 0.1340 0.1468 8.9 4.1 4.7

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Carlos Santana 0.1138 0.1288 0.1349 10.6 0.1 10.6
2 Mike Moustakas 0.0971 0.1135 0.1254 13.8 3.5 10.3
3 Wil Myers 0.1481 0.1338 0.1233 19.5 10.8 8.7
4 Adam Duvall 0.1348 0.1236 0.1206 12.5 5.9 6.6
5 Ender Inciarte 0.1342 0.1243 0.1295 7.1 0.6 6.5
6 Hunter Pence 0.1379 0.1255 0.1020 22.1 15.9 6.2
7 Charlie Blackmon 0.1274 0.1346 0.1890 40.9 35.0 5.9
8 Kyle Schwarber 0.1670 0.1550 0.1379 16.7 11.3 5.4
9 DJ LeMahieu 0.1177 0.1244 0.1393 11.2 6.0 5.2
10 Hunter Renfroe 0.1246 0.1132 0.1065 11.1 6.1 5.0

RBI Rate

Everybody Missed for RBI Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Jake Lamb 0.1654
0.1262
(25.0)
0.1236
(23.1)
0.1247
(24.4)
0.1277
(25.6)
J.D. Martinez 0.2127
0.1448
(33.2)
0.1415
(32.2)
0.1439
(32.5)
0.1458
(34.0)
Carlos González 0.1067
0.1548
(25.6)
0.1486
(25.2)
0.1571
(28.1)
0.1526
(23.1)
Anthony Rendon 0.1653
0.1204
(27.2)
0.1148
(27.3)
0.1216
(25.1)
0.1193
(29.4)
Kris Bryant 0.1098
0.1537
(29.1)
0.1415
(24.7)
0.1451
(25.0)
0.1622
(33.2)
Dexter Fowler 0.1303
0.0801
(24.7)
0.0795
(22.3)
0.0824
(22.4)
0.0779
(27.0)
Nomar Mazara 0.1640
0.1228
(25.4)
0.1111
(29.2)
0.1252
(22.5)
0.1204
(28.4)
Marcell Ozuna 0.1826
0.1290
(36.5)
0.1161
(41.5)
0.1350
(30.8)
0.1229
(42.3)
Yadier Molina 0.1510
0.1090
(22.9)
0.1030
(23.2)
0.1115
(20.2)
0.1065
(25.5)
Hanley Ramirez 0.1121
0.1568
(24.6)
0.1468
(22.1)
0.1522
(23.4)
0.1614
(25.8)
Paul Goldschmidt 0.1805
0.1418
(25.8)
0.1403
(23.1)
0.1345
(29.0)
0.1492
(22.5)
Mark Trumbo 0.1078
0.1641
(33.9)
0.1421
(23.9)
0.1577
(31.5)
0.1706
(36.3)
José Bautista 0.0948
0.1563
(42.2)
0.1465
(39.2)
0.1460
(36.7)
0.1667
(47.6)

Individual Misses for RBI Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Charlie Blackmon 0.1062 0.1434 27.1
2 Lorenzo Cain 0.1118 0.0760 23.0
3 Miguel Cabrera 0.1559 0.1134 22.4
4 Chris Davis 0.1592 0.1164 22.3
5 Willson Contreras 0.1227 0.1729 21.5
6 Carlos Beltrán 0.1426 0.1002 21.5
7 Rajai Davis 0.1133 0.0546 21.4

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Lorenzo Cain 0.1179 0.0760 30.5
2 Ian Kinsler 0.1174 0.0848 23.3
3 Jonathan Schoop 0.1166 0.1556 22.7
4 Miguel Cabrera 0.1495 0.1134 21.9
5 Willson Contreras 0.1171 0.1729 21.6
6 Jonathan Lucroy 0.1216 0.0832 21.1
7 Aledmys Díaz 0.1310 0.0664 21.1

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Charlie Blackmon 0.1055 0.1434 25.9
2 Lorenzo Cain 0.1102 0.0760 23.6
3 Miguel Cabrera 0.1556 0.1134 23.5
4 Rougned Odor 0.1464 0.1152 21.8
5 Jonathan Lucroy 0.1248 0.0832 21.1
6 Eric Thames 0.1502 0.1143 21.0
7 Carlos Beltrán 0.1373 0.1002 20.1

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Rajai Davis 0.1348 0.0546 28.4
2 Charlie Blackmon 0.1069 0.1434 28.3
3 Mike Moustakas 0.1024 0.1421 25.3
4 Chris Davis 0.1664 0.1164 24.9
5 Elvis Andrus 0.0967 0.1277 23.1
6 Willson Contreras 0.1216 0.1729 23.0
7 Carlos Beltrán 0.1478 0.1002 22.9

Most Unique Misses for RBI Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Hunter Renfroe 0.1435 0.1308 0.1211 13.3 4.6 8.7
2 José Peraza 0.0994 0.0890 0.0714 17.3 9.1 8.2
3 Javier Báez 0.1129 0.1336 0.1476 14.9 7.2 7.7
4 Lorenzo Cain 0.1179 0.1118 0.0760 30.5 23.0 7.5
5 Dansby Swanson 0.1099 0.1030 0.0926 12.5 5.7 6.8
6 Anthony Rizzo 0.1422 0.1587 0.1577 7.1 0.6 6.5
7 Edwin Encarnación 0.1705 0.1666 0.1599 10.7 4.4 6.3
8 Bryce Harper 0.1298 0.1471 0.1768 20.5 14.7 5.8
9 DJ LeMahieu 0.0983 0.0926 0.0938 6.7 1.0 5.7
10 Ian Kinsler 0.1174 0.1138 0.0848 23.3 17.7 5.6

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Manny Machado 0.1566 0.1448 0.1377 14.6 4.9 9.8
2 Carlos Correa 0.1368 0.1527 0.1746 17.1 10.6 6.5
3 Brandon Crawford 0.1091 0.1224 0.1351 13.5 7.3 6.2
4 Dee Strange-Gordon 0.0688 0.0625 0.0475 16.4 10.3 6.1
5 Jean Segura 0.0966 0.0901 0.0795 10.9 5.9 5.0
6 Jay Bruce 0.1330 0.1428 0.1637 17.5 13.0 4.6
7 Starling Marte 0.1187 0.1084 0.0914 10.0 5.7 4.3
8 Billy Hamilton 0.0707 0.0665 0.0600 8.2 4.0 4.2
9 Carlos Gómez 0.1069 0.1181 0.1197 4.5 0.7 3.7
10 Adam Duvall 0.1426 0.1506 0.1530 5.2 1.7 3.6

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Mike Moustakas 0.1024 0.1167 0.1421 25.3 15.3 10.0
2 Albert Pujols 0.1842 0.1687 0.1588 14.5 6.2 8.3
3 Kyle Schwarber 0.1692 0.1519 0.1214 22.0 14.8 7.2
4 Rajai Davis 0.1348 0.1133 0.0546 28.4 21.4 7.0
5 Ender Inciarte 0.0621 0.0686 0.0794 14.3 7.8 6.4
6 Michael Brantley 0.1629 0.1435 0.1387 8.1 1.7 6.4
7 Russell Martin 0.1537 0.1349 0.0959 20.2 14.2 6.0
8 Mookie Betts 0.1338 0.1397 0.1433 8.5 2.6 6.0
9 Marcell Ozuna 0.1229 0.1290 0.1826 42.3 36.5 5.7
10 Corey Seager 0.1467 0.1349 0.1256 11.3 5.6 5.7

Batting Average

Everybody Missed for Batting Average

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Jonathan Schoop 0.2926
0.2628
(20.9)
0.2556
(27.1)
0.2612
(22.4)
0.2644
(19.4)
José Ramírez 0.3179
0.2858
(21.5)
0.2744
(30.2)
0.2866
(21.4)
0.2849
(21.6)
Eric Hosmer 0.3184
0.2774
(28.3)
0.2742
(31.8)
0.2781
(28.3)
0.2767
(28.3)
Rougned Odor 0.2043
0.2747
(45.0)
0.2638
(36.7)
0.2748
(44.7)
0.2745
(45.4)
Miguel Cabrera 0.2495
0.3056
(29.1)
0.3104
(30.6)
0.3099
(31.0)
0.3014
(27.2)
Marcell Ozuna 0.3116
0.2687
(29.9)
0.2626
(35.4)
0.2726
(27.7)
0.2649
(32.1)
Charlie Blackmon 0.3307
0.2930
(28.3)
0.2949
(28.3)
0.2883
(32.1)
0.2976
(24.4)
Justin Turner 0.3217
0.2782
(24.3)
0.2848
(21.7)
0.2779
(24.8)
0.2785
(23.8)
Mike Napoli 0.1929
0.2340
(19.3)
0.2391
(20.9)
0.2345
(19.3)
0.2335
(19.4)
José Bautista 0.2027
0.2503
(31.8)
0.2541
(33.1)
0.2488
(30.3)
0.2518
(33.3)
Mookie Betts 0.2643
0.3083
(30.5)
0.2988
(22.3)
0.3097
(31.0)
0.3070
(30.0)

Individual Misses for Batting Average

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Maikel Franco 0.2706 0.2296 24.8
2 Joey Votto 0.2898 0.3202 22.3
3 Manny Machado 0.2912 0.2587 21.6
4 Ian Kinsler 0.2716 0.2359 21.1
5 Hanley Ramirez 0.2808 0.2419 20.8
6 Jose Altuve 0.3156 0.3458 20.8
7 Kyle Schwarber 0.2537 0.2109 20.2
8 Brad Miller 0.2495 0.2012 19.2
9 Carlos Beltrán 0.2701 0.2313 19.2

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Ian Kinsler 0.2823 0.2359 26.5
2 Bryce Harper 0.2764 0.3190 22.5
3 Carlos Correa 0.2719 0.3152 22.3
4 Dansby Swanson 0.2727 0.2316 20.9
5 Anthony Rendon 0.2715 0.3012 19.9
6 Carlos Beltrán 0.2727 0.2313 19.5
7 Eduardo Núñez 0.2762 0.3126 19.5
8 Alex Bregman 0.2568 0.2842 19.1
9 Elvis Andrus 0.2733 0.2970 18.5

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Kyle Schwarber 0.2643 0.2109 25.0
2 Maikel Franco 0.2715 0.2296 25.0
3 Joey Votto 0.2883 0.3202 23.9
4 Jose Altuve 0.3120 0.3458 23.6
5 Eduardo Núñez 0.2679 0.3126 22.9
6 Manny Machado 0.2936 0.2587 22.8
7 Dee Strange-Gordon 0.2783 0.3078 21.8
8 Hanley Ramirez 0.2814 0.2419 20.8
9 Brad Miller 0.2511 0.2012 19.6

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Maikel Franco 0.2697 0.2296 24.6
2 Ian Kinsler 0.2754 0.2359 23.9
3 Hanley Ramirez 0.2803 0.2419 20.9
4 Joey Votto 0.2914 0.3202 20.7
5 Manny Machado 0.2889 0.2587 20.4
6 George Springer 0.2515 0.2828 20.1
7 Carlos Beltrán 0.2712 0.2313 20.1
8 Bryce Harper 0.2798 0.3190 19.6
9 Anthony Rendon 0.2697 0.3012 19.3

Most Unique Misses for Batting Average

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Hunter Renfroe 0.2709 0.2440 0.2315 17.4 5.4 12.0
2 Byron Buxton 0.2316 0.2510 0.2532 12.7 1.7 10.9
3 Keon Broxton 0.2456 0.2188 0.2198 10.5 1.0 9.5
4 José Ramírez 0.2744 0.2858 0.3179 30.2 21.5 8.6
5 Dansby Swanson 0.2727 0.2560 0.2316 20.9 12.8 8.2
6 Alex Bregman 0.2568 0.2665 0.2842 19.1 11.8 7.3
7 Jonathan Schoop 0.2556 0.2628 0.2926 27.1 20.9 6.2
8 Russell Martin 0.2489 0.2307 0.2215 8.8 2.9 5.9
9 Daniel Murphy 0.3024 0.3102 0.3221 13.5 7.8 5.8
10 Carlos Santana 0.2446 0.2509 0.2592 11.8 6.3 5.5

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Eric Thames 0.2715 0.2590 0.2473 12.3 5.8 6.5
2 Matt Holliday 0.2714 0.2576 0.2306 16.6 11.0 5.6
3 Kyle Schwarber 0.2643 0.2537 0.2109 25.0 20.2 4.8
4 Byron Buxton 0.2433 0.2510 0.2532 6.0 1.7 4.3
5 Christian Yelich 0.2942 0.2874 0.2824 6.9 2.6 4.3
6 Edwin Encarnación 0.2536 0.2591 0.2581 4.2 0.1 4.1
7 Eduardo Núñez 0.2679 0.2755 0.3126 22.9 18.8 4.1
8 Adam Duvall 0.2330 0.2385 0.2487 11.4 7.4 4.0
9 Trea Turner 0.3009 0.2915 0.2840 6.7 2.8 3.9
10 Charlie Blackmon 0.2883 0.2930 0.3307 32.1 28.3 3.9

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Giancarlo Stanton 0.2542 0.2612 0.2814 19.2 14.8 4.4
2 Edwin Encarnación 0.2646 0.2591 0.2581 4.0 0.1 3.9
3 José Reyes 0.2673 0.2615 0.2455 11.9 8.3 3.6
4 Mike Moustakas 0.2543 0.2607 0.2721 10.9 7.5 3.4
5 Francisco Lindor 0.2980 0.2940 0.2734 17.4 14.0 3.4
6 Daniel Murphy 0.3039 0.3102 0.3221 11.1 7.8 3.3
7 Gary Sánchez 0.2549 0.2615 0.2781 12.5 9.3 3.1
8 Hunter Pence 0.2758 0.2710 0.2596 8.4 5.5 2.9
9 Ian Kinsler 0.2754 0.2716 0.2359 23.9 21.1 2.7
10 Brandon Crawford 0.2612 0.2573 0.2529 4.4 1.8 2.6

Pitching Projection Accuracy

Batters Faced (BF)

Everybody Missed for Batters Faced (BF)

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Julio Urías 102
513
(410.8)
417
(315.0)
441
(338.6)
585
(483.0)
Vince Velasquez 315
629
(314.3)
532
(217.0)
668
(352.6)
591
(276.0)
Joe Ross 323
596
(272.5)
512
(189.0)
624
(301.1)
567
(244.0)
David Price 317
732
(414.9)
803
(486.0)
550
(232.9)
914
(597.0)
Matt Shoemaker 326
714
(388.0)
629
(303.0)
809
(483.0)
619
(293.0)
Michael Pineda 410
642
(232.2)
696
(286.0)
624
(214.4)
660
(250.0)
Félix Hernández 368
815
(446.8)
646
(278.0)
865
(496.7)
765
(397.0)
Steven Matz 298
569
(270.9)
552
(254.0)
554
(255.7)
584
(286.0)
Noah Syndergaard 124
790
(665.9)
696
(572.0)
809
(684.8)
771
(647.0)
Aaron Sanchez 167
851
(684.2)
636
(469.0)
871
(704.4)
831
(664.0)
Garrett Richards 108
577
(469.0)
410
(302.0)
665
(557.0)
489
(381.0)
Danny Salazar 439
706
(267.3)
626
(187.0)
714
(274.5)
699
(260.0)
Carlos Rodón 297
667
(370.1)
684
(387.0)
611
(314.2)
723
(426.0)
Madison Bumgarner 450
862
(411.6)
795
(345.0)
858
(408.2)
865
(415.0)

Individual Misses for Batters Faced (BF)

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Drew Pomeranz 429 740 311.0
2 Jon Gray 738 461 277.4
3 Iván Nova 516 785 268.9
4 Cole Hamels 851 614 236.7
5 Dallas Keuchel 809 584 225.1
6 Johnny Cueto 870 648 222.5

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Yu Darvish 459 766 307.0
2 Gerrit Cole 587 849 262.0
3 Jharel Cotton 317 566 249.0
4 Jacob deGrom 623 827 204.0
5 Carlos Carrasco 595 798 203.0
6 Jeurys Familia 298 111 187.0

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Drew Pomeranz 272 740 468.1
2 Jon Gray 794 461 332.8
3 Iván Nova 512 785 272.9
4 Cole Hamels 873 614 259.5
5 Dallas Keuchel 841 584 257.3
6 Johnny Cueto 875 648 226.9

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Iván Nova 520 785 265.0
2 Matt Moore 545 790 245.0
3 Marcus Stroman 601 834 233.0
4 Jon Gray 683 461 222.0
5 Johnny Cueto 866 648 218.0
6 Cole Hamels 828 614 214.0

Most Unique Misses for Batters Faced (BF)

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Yu Darvish 459 703 766 307.0 63.4 243.6
2 Jharel Cotton 317 618 566 249.0 52.0 197.0
3 Gerrit Cole 587 740 849 262.0 109.3 152.7
4 Carlos Martinez 712 837 858 146.0 21.1 124.9
5 Carlos Carrasco 595 717 798 203.0 80.6 122.4
6 Aaron Nola 541 738 693 152.0 45.2 106.8
7 Zack Greinke 646 751 801 155.0 49.8 105.2
8 Sean Manaea 558 660 692 134.0 32.2 101.8
9 Jameson Taillon 470 606 587 117.0 18.8 98.2
10 Jacob deGrom 623 715 827 204.0 111.8 92.2

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Drew Pomeranz 272 429 740 468.1 311.0 157.1
2 Jameson Taillon 731 606 587 143.5 18.8 124.8
3 James Paxton 715 613 552 162.5 60.8 101.8
4 Matt Shoemaker 809 714 326 483.0 388.0 95.0
5 Garrett Richards 665 577 108 557.0 469.0 88.0
6 Masahiro Tanaka 852 771 752 100.3 19.1 81.1
7 J.A. Happ 787 725 626 160.8 98.9 61.9
8 Clayton Kershaw 817 756 679 138.4 77.2 61.2
9 Jon Gray 794 738 461 332.8 277.4 55.4
10 Lance McCullers Jr. 630 578 512 117.6 65.8 51.8

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 David Price 914 732 317 597.0 414.9 182.1
2 Matt Moore 545 651 790 245.0 138.9 106.1
3 Yu Darvish 597 703 766 169.0 63.4 105.6
4 Rich Hill 404 506 552 148.0 46.1 101.9
5 Jameson Taillon 481 606 587 106.0 18.8 87.2
6 Justin Verlander 711 787 849 138.0 61.7 76.3
7 Julio Urías 585 513 102 483.0 410.8 72.2
8 Jerad Eickhoff 783 715 576 207.0 139.1 67.9
9 Kenta Maeda 749 684 557 192.0 127.2 64.8
10 Greg Holland 154 215 235 81.0 20.2 60.8

Strikeout Rate

Everybody Missed for Strikeout Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Robbie Ray 0.3278
0.2706
(30.8)
0.2447
(46.2)
0.2616
(35.6)
0.2796
(26.1)
James Paxton 0.2826
0.2170
(30.2)
0.2126
(31.1)
0.2207
(27.2)
0.2133
(33.3)
Cole Hamels 0.1710
0.2132
(32.6)
0.2326
(46.2)
0.2126
(33.3)
0.2138
(31.8)
Jeff Samardzija 0.2420
0.1990
(27.2)
0.2008
(23.3)
0.1950
(29.1)
0.2030
(25.4)
Chris Sale 0.3619
0.2629
(75.0)
0.2695
(67.0)
0.2515
(83.2)
0.2743
(66.9)
Corey Kluber 0.3411
0.2595
(54.9)
0.2595
(52.7)
0.2540
(57.8)
0.2650
(52.0)
Zack Greinke 0.2684
0.2080
(39.7)
0.2198
(28.0)
0.2040
(41.5)
0.2119
(38.0)
Jacob deGrom 0.2890
0.2371
(33.9)
0.2424
(27.2)
0.2356
(33.7)
0.2386
(34.2)
Michael Fulmer 0.1686
0.2008
(29.1)
0.2054
(34.1)
0.2025
(31.5)
0.1991
(26.7)
Matt Moore 0.1873
0.2196
(34.1)
0.2048
(24.6)
0.2264
(40.9)
0.2128
(27.3)
Craig Kimbrel 0.4961
0.3344
(38.3)
0.2983
(46.8)
0.3240
(40.5)
0.3448
(36.1)
Max Scherzer 0.3436
0.2946
(29.7)
0.2877
(32.9)
0.2984
(25.4)
0.2908
(34.1)
Jose Quintana 0.2620
0.2092
(33.1)
0.2115
(29.1)
0.2103
(30.9)
0.2082
(35.4)

Individual Misses for Strikeout Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Julio Teheran 0.2098 0.1860 28.1
2 Jharel Cotton 0.2230 0.1855 27.4
3 Masahiro Tanaka 0.2108 0.2580 27.3
4 Aaron Nola 0.2163 0.2655 26.6
5 Steven Matz 0.2381 0.1611 26.2
6 Danny Salazar 0.2598 0.3303 26.2
7 Seunghwan Oh 0.2893 0.2045 25.2

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Matt Harvey 0.2171 0.1555 32.5
2 Julio Teheran 0.2112 0.1860 31.6
3 Danny Salazar 0.2508 0.3303 28.9
4 Ian Kennedy 0.2283 0.2000 27.5
5 Kenley Jansen 0.3125 0.4225 24.8
6 Iván Nova 0.1839 0.1669 24.1
7 Sam Dyson 0.2064 0.1308 23.2

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Julio Teheran 0.2145 0.1860 33.5
2 Matt Harvey 0.2193 0.1555 33.0
3 Masahiro Tanaka 0.2043 0.2580 30.8
4 Danny Salazar 0.2492 0.3303 30.0
5 Jharel Cotton 0.2205 0.1855 27.0
6 Steven Matz 0.2348 0.1611 25.7
7 Sam Dyson 0.2024 0.1308 21.9

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Aaron Nola 0.2080 0.2655 33.6
2 Marco Estrada 0.1704 0.2184 31.4
3 Seunghwan Oh 0.3092 0.2045 30.0
4 Jharel Cotton 0.2255 0.1855 27.8
5 Steven Matz 0.2414 0.1611 26.6
6 Tanner Roark 0.1714 0.2139 26.0
7 Alex Colomé 0.2874 0.2064 25.3

Most Unique Misses for Strikeout Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Kenley Jansen 0.3125 0.3751 0.4225 24.8 9.4 15.4
2 Robbie Ray 0.2447 0.2706 0.3278 46.2 30.8 15.3
3 Cole Hamels 0.2326 0.2132 0.1710 46.2 32.6 13.7
4 Johnny Cueto 0.2205 0.2036 0.2099 15.7 3.0 12.8
5 Wade Davis 0.2617 0.3159 0.3264 12.4 0.1 12.3
6 Jake Arrieta 0.2458 0.2315 0.2306 20.5 8.4 12.1
7 Ian Kennedy 0.2283 0.2141 0.2000 27.5 16.3 11.2
8 Iván Nova 0.1839 0.1726 0.1669 24.1 13.0 11.1
9 Ken Giles 0.2806 0.3238 0.3360 10.3 0.3 10.0
10 Brandon Kintzler 0.1818 0.1508 0.1354 17.3 7.6 9.7

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Chris Sale 0.2515 0.2629 0.3619 83.2 75.0 8.1
2 Matt Harvey 0.2193 0.2031 0.1555 33.0 25.2 7.7
3 Matt Moore 0.2264 0.2196 0.1873 40.9 34.1 6.8
4 Carlos Carrasco 0.2465 0.2565 0.2832 19.2 12.7 6.5
5 Wade Davis 0.2894 0.3159 0.3264 5.9 0.1 5.8
6 David Robertson 0.2761 0.2993 0.3712 21.8 16.1 5.7
7 Iván Nova 0.1778 0.1726 0.1669 18.5 13.0 5.5
8 Julio Teheran 0.2145 0.2098 0.1860 33.5 28.1 5.3
9 Yu Darvish 0.2816 0.2765 0.2728 16.4 11.1 5.3
10 Jameson Taillon 0.2124 0.1987 0.2129 7.1 2.0 5.1

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Marco Estrada 0.1704 0.1830 0.2184 31.4 19.7 11.6
2 Justin Verlander 0.2278 0.2373 0.2580 17.9 8.3 9.5
3 Edwin Díaz 0.3727 0.3378 0.3201 17.1 7.9 9.2
4 Jameson Taillon 0.1850 0.1987 0.2129 11.1 2.0 9.1
5 Aaron Nola 0.2080 0.2163 0.2655 33.6 26.6 7.1
6 Tanner Roark 0.1714 0.1783 0.2139 26.0 19.2 6.7
7 Wade Davis 0.3423 0.3159 0.3264 6.0 0.1 6.0
8 Alex Colomé 0.2874 0.2659 0.2064 25.3 19.8 5.5
9 Jake Arrieta 0.2410 0.2315 0.2306 13.8 8.4 5.4
10 Seunghwan Oh 0.3092 0.2893 0.2045 30.0 25.2 4.8

Win Rate

Everybody Missed for Win Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Robbie Ray 0.5357
0.3874
(103.7)
0.1905
(163.0)
0.3684
(109.5)
0.4062
(98.3)
Drew Pomeranz 0.5312
0.4051
(99.0)
0.1739
(190.3)
0.3860
(105.5)
0.4231
(93.6)
Dallas Keuchel 0.6087
0.4508
(96.7)
0.3143
(113.4)
0.4375
(98.4)
0.4643
(95.0)
Jeff Samardzija 0.2812
0.3728
(71.0)
0.2632
(69.5)
0.3665
(74.6)
0.3793
(67.5)
Corey Kluber 0.6207
0.4842
(112.0)
0.3158
(159.1)
0.4531
(128.1)
0.5161
(95.5)
Rick Porcello 0.3333
0.4562
(101.9)
0.3500
(103.4)
0.4137
(73.6)
0.5000
(131.3)
Ian Kennedy 0.1667
0.3581
(120.3)
0.2564
(124.4)
0.3366
(113.1)
0.3793
(127.3)
Clayton Kershaw 0.6667
0.5298
(98.2)
0.3750
(130.0)
0.5212
(96.9)
0.5385
(99.5)
Danny Salazar 0.2174
0.4115
(81.8)
0.3056
(82.7)
0.3947
(79.1)
0.4286
(84.7)
Carlos Carrasco 0.5625
0.4451
(99.8)
0.2778
(147.3)
0.4291
(104.2)
0.4615
(95.2)
Jacob deGrom 0.4839
0.3834
(89.5)
0.2571
(104.7)
0.3822
(81.8)
0.3846
(97.2)
Matt Moore 0.1875
0.3871
(151.6)
0.2381
(119.1)
0.3653
(142.6)
0.4091
(160.6)
Madison Bumgarner 0.2353
0.4629
(99.0)
0.3500
(96.7)
0.4262
(87.1)
0.5000
(110.9)
Jerad Eickhoff 0.1667
0.3522
(102.4)
0.2143
(85.1)
0.3176
(88.5)
0.3871
(116.4)

Individual Misses for Win Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Chris Archer 0.4190 0.2941 99.8
2 Zack Greinke 0.4196 0.5312 95.6
3 James Paxton 0.3450 0.5000 89.8
4 Johnny Cueto 0.4346 0.3200 69.3
5 Jon Gray 0.3598 0.5000 68.2
6 Yu Darvish 0.4178 0.3226 67.0

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 James Paxton 0.2059 0.5000 107.1
2 Jon Gray 0.1951 0.5000 94.4
3 Sean Manaea 0.1842 0.4138 89.6
4 Aaron Nola 0.2222 0.4444 84.6
5 Chris Sale 0.3333 0.5312 83.2
6 Johnny Cueto 0.3421 0.3200 79.2

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Zack Greinke 0.3731 0.5312 124.4
2 Chris Archer 0.4004 0.2941 92.9
3 Yu Darvish 0.4189 0.3226 75.9
4 Adam Wainwright 0.3729 0.5000 67.9
5 Stephen Strasburg 0.4381 0.5357 66.5
6 Kyle Hendricks 0.4045 0.2917 65.9

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 James Paxton 0.3043 0.5000 118.1
2 Chris Archer 0.4375 0.2941 106.6
3 Johnny Cueto 0.4667 0.3200 83.2
4 Jon Gray 0.3448 0.5000 80.0
5 Sean Manaea 0.3333 0.4138 68.4
6 Zack Greinke 0.4643 0.5312 68.3

Most Unique Misses for Win Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Drew Pomeranz 0.1739 0.4051 0.5312 190.3 99.0 91.3
2 Robbie Ray 0.1905 0.3874 0.5357 163.0 103.7 59.2
3 Chris Sale 0.3333 0.5091 0.5312 83.2 25.4 57.8
4 Raisel Iglesias 0.1176 0.0585 0.0476 52.1 1.0 51.1
5 Carlos Carrasco 0.2778 0.4451 0.5625 147.3 99.8 47.4
6 Corey Kluber 0.3158 0.4842 0.6207 159.1 112.0 47.0
7 Alex Colomé 0.1053 0.0586 0.0308 49.1 5.6 43.4
8 Addison Reed 0.0727 0.0526 0.0260 45.0 5.8 39.2
9 Rich Hill 0.2647 0.4408 0.4800 63.5 25.9 37.7
10 Héctor Neris 0.0800 0.0524 0.0541 40.4 3.0 37.3

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Zack Greinke 0.3731 0.4196 0.5312 124.4 95.6 28.8
2 Chris Sale 0.4679 0.5091 0.5312 51.5 25.4 26.1
3 Jameson Taillon 0.3835 0.3498 0.3200 38.9 13.0 25.9
4 Matt Harvey 0.3616 0.3125 0.2632 43.6 17.9 25.7
5 Jake Arrieta 0.4299 0.4655 0.4667 24.0 6.3 17.8
6 Corey Kluber 0.4531 0.4842 0.6207 128.1 112.0 16.0
7 Lance McCullers Jr. 0.4027 0.3830 0.3182 44.7 29.2 15.5
8 Tanner Roark 0.3695 0.3990 0.4062 26.4 11.6 14.8
9 Kenta Maeda 0.3785 0.4120 0.4483 37.3 24.5 12.8
10 Rich Hill 0.4095 0.4408 0.4800 37.4 25.9 11.5

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Rick Porcello 0.5000 0.4562 0.3333 131.3 101.9 29.4
2 James Paxton 0.3043 0.3450 0.5000 118.1 89.8 28.3
3 Masahiro Tanaka 0.3704 0.3844 0.4333 61.1 42.6 18.5
4 Gerrit Cole 0.4444 0.4135 0.3636 53.1 35.8 17.3
5 Jharel Cotton 0.3043 0.3227 0.3750 50.4 34.0 16.4
6 Iván Nova 0.4000 0.3703 0.3548 21.1 6.1 15.0
7 Carlos Martinez 0.4516 0.4237 0.3750 50.0 35.2 14.9
8 Cole Hamels 0.3667 0.3800 0.4583 67.5 52.8 14.7
9 Michael Pineda 0.3571 0.3812 0.4706 54.0 39.8 14.2
10 Jerad Eickhoff 0.3871 0.3522 0.1667 116.4 102.4 14.0

Save Rate

Everybody Missed for Save Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Addison Reed 0.2468
0.0892
(48.2)
0.0909
(48.2)
0.0516
(61.5)
0.1250
(35.3)
Héctor Neris 0.3514
0.1030
(79.5)
0.0400
(100.2)
0.1692
(60.2)
0.0286
(101.3)
Ryan Madson 0.0333
0.3978
(79.8)
0.2340
(43.6)
0.3600
(70.2)
0.4348
(89.3)
Fernando Rodney 0.6393
0.4163
(51.5)
0.3061
(77.4)
0.4467
(45.9)
0.3860
(57.1)
Andrew Miller 0.0351
0.2833
(60.6)
0.2115
(42.6)
0.3016
(63.6)
0.2656
(57.8)
David Robertson 0.2295
0.5679
(89.4)
0.4468
(56.9)
0.4992
(69.7)
0.6379
(109.5)
Ken Giles 0.5397
0.3154
(55.4)
0.1569
(95.0)
0.4144
(32.4)
0.2143
(78.8)

Individual Misses for Save Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Alex Colomé 0.5138 0.7231 58.8
2 Tony Watson 0.3292 0.1408 54.8
3 Raisel Iglesias 0.2680 0.4444 54.0
4 Francisco Rodríguez 0.6309 0.2500 45.0
5 Jeurys Familia 0.5996 0.2308 40.9
6 Greg Holland 0.5006 0.6721 40.3
7 Jim Johnson 0.2076 0.3607 39.2
8 Mark Melancon 0.6149 0.3438 35.3
9 Edwin Díaz 0.3892 0.5152 35.0
10 Sam Dyson 0.3865 0.2545 34.3

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Alex Colomé 0.3158 0.7231 114.9
2 Raisel Iglesias 0.0882 0.4444 109.5
3 Kelvin Herrera 0.0741 0.4062 86.5
4 Edwin Díaz 0.2121 0.5152 84.7
5 Brandon Kintzler 0.1622 0.4028 69.8
6 Roberto Osuna 0.3148 0.5909 69.2
7 Blake Treinen 0.0208 0.2222 66.0
8 Wade Davis 0.2750 0.5424 65.1
9 Greg Holland 0.4000 0.6721 64.4
10 Brandon Maurer 0.1020 0.3235 59.6

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Tony Watson 0.5564 0.1408 119.2
2 Greg Holland 0.2673 0.6721 96.5
3 Alex Colomé 0.4213 0.7231 86.5
4 Cam Bedrosian 0.5061 0.1250 71.3
5 Sam Dyson 0.5164 0.2545 66.6
6 Seunghwan Oh 0.5475 0.3226 57.8
7 Neftalí Feliz 0.4448 0.1633 54.0
8 Cody Allen 0.2714 0.4348 47.7
9 Jim Johnson 0.1805 0.3607 47.6
10 Brandon Kintzler 0.2652 0.4028 41.3

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Raisel Iglesias 0.0000 0.4444 134.1
2 Edwin Díaz 0.2368 0.5152 75.6
3 Kelvin Herrera 0.1127 0.4062 74.4
4 Blake Treinen 0.0147 0.2222 65.4
5 Francisco Rodríguez 0.7455 0.2500 59.2
6 Roberto Osuna 0.4028 0.5909 45.3
7 Iván Nova 0.0500 0.0000 44.2
8 Jeurys Familia 0.6184 0.2308 43.7
9 Mark Melancon 0.6429 0.3438 39.7
10 Zack Britton 0.6212 0.3947 37.5

Most Unique Misses for Save Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Wade Davis 0.2750 0.5421 0.5424 65.1 0.1 65.1
2 Kelvin Herrera 0.0741 0.3108 0.4062 86.5 24.7 61.8
3 Brandon Maurer 0.1020 0.3236 0.3235 59.6 0.0 59.6
4 Alex Colomé 0.3158 0.5138 0.7231 114.9 58.8 56.2
5 Raisel Iglesias 0.0882 0.2680 0.4444 109.5 54.0 55.6
6 Blake Treinen 0.0208 0.1868 0.2222 66.0 11.5 54.5
7 Edwin Díaz 0.2121 0.3892 0.5152 84.7 35.0 49.7
8 Ken Giles 0.1569 0.3154 0.5397 95.0 55.4 39.6
9 Brandon Kintzler 0.1622 0.2956 0.4028 69.8 30.8 39.0
10 Jharel Cotton 0.0667 0.0000 0.0000 36.7 0.0 36.7

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Tony Watson 0.5564 0.3292 0.1408 119.2 54.8 64.4
2 Greg Holland 0.2673 0.5006 0.6721 96.5 40.3 56.2
3 Cam Bedrosian 0.5061 0.2722 0.1250 71.3 28.0 43.3
4 Neftalí Feliz 0.4448 0.2602 0.1633 54.0 19.0 35.0
5 Seunghwan Oh 0.5475 0.4089 0.3226 57.8 22.8 35.0
6 Sam Dyson 0.5164 0.3865 0.2545 66.6 34.3 32.2
7 Brandon Maurer 0.4501 0.3236 0.3235 32.2 0.0 32.2
8 Blake Treinen 0.3491 0.1868 0.2222 39.3 11.5 27.8
9 Alex Colomé 0.4213 0.5138 0.7231 86.5 58.8 27.7
10 Cody Allen 0.2714 0.3589 0.4348 47.7 21.4 26.3

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Raisel Iglesias 0.0000 0.2680 0.4444 134.1 54.0 80.1
2 Blake Treinen 0.0147 0.1868 0.2222 65.4 11.5 53.9
3 Kelvin Herrera 0.1127 0.3108 0.4062 74.4 24.7 49.7
4 Edwin Díaz 0.2368 0.3892 0.5152 75.6 35.0 40.6
5 Brandon Maurer 0.1970 0.3236 0.3235 32.1 0.0 32.1
6 Iván Nova 0.0500 0.0242 0.0000 44.2 19.0 25.2
7 Ken Giles 0.2143 0.3154 0.5397 78.8 55.4 23.4
8 Héctor Neris 0.0286 0.1030 0.3514 101.3 79.5 21.8
9 David Robertson 0.6379 0.5679 0.2295 109.5 89.4 20.1
10 AJ Ramos 0.5606 0.4962 0.4426 32.1 13.8 18.2

ERA

Everybody Missed for ERA

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Robbie Ray 2.8889
3.6795
(723.9)
4.4417
(1258.0)
3.6343
(625.7)
3.7259
(822.6)
Jon Lester 4.3339
3.2515
(598.5)
3.0050
(755.4)
3.4195
(548.6)
3.0844
(648.2)
Matt Harvey 6.7014
3.7911
(1125.9)
3.7143
(1141.4)
3.7530
(1186.5)
3.8298
(1065.3)
Taijuan Walker 3.4894
4.2306
(710.8)
4.2302
(738.6)
4.1741
(602.0)
4.2876
(819.5)
Marcus Stroman 3.0896
3.8470
(880.3)
4.0663
(1097.2)
3.7291
(696.4)
3.9668
(1065.2)
Stephen Strasburg 2.5152
3.1960
(686.1)
3.5607
(970.5)
3.2852
(676.8)
3.1067
(695.0)
Corey Kluber 2.2537
3.2622
(1015.1)
3.2927
(1070.7)
3.4179
(1056.5)
3.1054
(972.6)
Jharel Cotton 5.5814
4.0928
(673.9)
3.5294
(969.6)
4.1604
(693.6)
4.0240
(655.1)
Ian Kennedy 5.3766
4.1722
(593.7)
3.9108
(738.1)
4.3396
(551.2)
4.0020
(638.4)
Sam Dyson 6.0915
3.5445
(584.7)
3.0576
(700.7)
3.6333
(588.3)
3.4550
(581.5)
Steven Matz 6.0750
3.5031
(677.6)
3.5428
(653.6)
3.5493
(694.4)
3.4565
(661.1)
Johnny Cueto 4.5204
3.2365
(638.9)
3.0806
(713.4)
3.4399
(573.5)
3.0337
(704.2)
Matt Moore 5.5239
3.7408
(1173.2)
4.2162
(765.3)
3.6675
(1312.1)
3.8160
(1033.2)
Max Scherzer 2.5116
3.0845
(679.3)
3.1433
(757.1)
3.1777
(672.0)
2.9905
(685.5)

Individual Misses for ERA

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Zack Greinke 3.7183 3.2026 651.7
2 Brandon Maurer 3.8997 6.5225 620.7
3 Drew Pomeranz 3.8384 3.3167 606.6
4 James Paxton 3.7384 2.9779 584.2
5 Dallas Keuchel 3.5953 2.9039 577.8
6 J.A. Happ 4.1087 3.5298 548.9

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Marco Estrada 3.5954 4.9839 845.9
2 Masahiro Tanaka 3.3390 4.7439 801.6
3 Tanner Roark 3.3736 4.6654 739.4
4 Aaron Nola 4.2520 3.5357 731.2
5 Chris Sale 3.3623 2.8974 684.1
6 James Paxton 3.8208 2.9779 652.3

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Brandon Maurer 3.6500 6.5225 714.8
2 Chris Sale 3.4952 2.8974 675.1
3 Zack Greinke 3.8336 3.2026 662.0
4 Drew Pomeranz 3.9883 3.3167 641.7
5 J.A. Happ 4.2599 3.5298 579.4
6 Adam Wainwright 3.9005 5.1081 552.6

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 James Paxton 3.9549 2.9779 760.1
2 Dallas Keuchel 3.6552 2.9039 672.4
3 Zack Greinke 3.6035 3.2026 641.5
4 Rick Porcello 3.5478 4.6475 619.3
5 Marco Estrada 3.8429 4.9839 597.2
6 Justin Verlander 3.6673 3.3641 597.1

Most Unique Misses for ERA

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Marco Estrada 3.5954 4.3234 4.9839 845.9 292.2 553.7
2 Robbie Ray 4.4417 3.6795 2.8889 1258.0 723.9 534.1
3 Tanner Roark 3.3736 4.0476 4.6654 739.4 248.2 491.2
4 Aaron Nola 4.2520 3.6422 3.5357 731.2 280.3 450.9
5 Iván Nova 4.3978 4.0198 4.1390 469.2 140.3 328.9
6 Jharel Cotton 3.5294 4.0928 5.5814 969.6 673.9 295.7
7 Masahiro Tanaka 3.3390 3.7730 4.7439 801.6 506.1 295.5
8 Stephen Strasburg 3.5607 3.1960 2.5152 970.5 686.1 284.4
9 Jake Arrieta 2.7922 3.2731 3.5287 281.1 29.9 251.1
10 Julio Teheran 3.5553 3.9005 4.4920 485.4 238.3 247.1

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Chris Sale 3.4952 3.1453 2.8974 675.1 464.6 210.5
2 Matt Moore 3.6675 3.7408 5.5239 1312.1 1173.2 138.9
3 Michael Pineda 3.5186 3.7387 4.3910 277.5 145.3 132.2
4 Jake Arrieta 3.5350 3.2731 3.5287 142.7 29.9 112.8
5 Chris Archer 3.3827 3.3960 4.0746 423.0 324.3 98.7
6 Brandon Maurer 3.6500 3.8997 6.5225 714.8 620.7 94.1
7 Jameson Taillon 3.5969 3.6406 4.4439 382.4 296.6 85.8
8 Kyle Hendricks 3.6915 3.4515 3.0286 489.2 410.9 78.4
9 Adam Wainwright 3.9005 3.9389 5.1081 552.6 475.7 76.9
10 Neftalí Feliz 3.8292 4.1085 5.4783 284.9 210.1 74.8

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Marco Estrada 3.8429 4.3234 4.9839 597.2 292.2 305.1
2 Marcus Stroman 3.9668 3.8470 3.0896 1065.2 880.3 185.0
3 James Paxton 3.9549 3.7384 2.9779 760.1 584.2 175.9
4 Rick Porcello 3.5478 3.7759 4.6475 619.3 507.7 111.6
5 Taijuan Walker 4.2876 4.2306 3.4894 819.5 710.8 108.7
6 Robbie Ray 3.7259 3.6795 2.8889 822.6 723.9 98.7
7 Dallas Keuchel 3.6552 3.5953 2.9039 672.4 577.8 94.6
8 John Lackey 3.5151 3.7453 4.5879 491.8 398.1 93.7
9 Justin Verlander 3.6673 3.6594 3.3641 597.1 503.7 93.3
10 Julio Teheran 3.7005 3.9005 4.4920 317.9 238.3 79.6

WHIP

Everybody Missed for WHIP

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Jon Lester 1.3229
1.1322
(122.7)
1.1074
(131.0)
1.1733
(106.6)
1.0914
(138.6)
Matt Harvey 1.6942
1.2183
(192.2)
1.2381
(177.7)
1.2168
(201.5)
1.2199
(183.0)
Chris Sale 0.9705
1.0916
(128.6)
1.0901
(139.0)
1.1264
(141.2)
1.0568
(115.8)
Jerad Eickhoff 1.5234
1.2454
(142.9)
1.1889
(167.5)
1.2812
(133.8)
1.2098
(152.0)
Corey Kluber 0.8691
1.1258
(222.7)
1.1082
(219.8)
1.1492
(225.4)
1.1022
(219.9)
Rick Porcello 1.3967
1.2081
(140.5)
1.1777
(155.1)
1.2334
(135.8)
1.1826
(145.4)
Sam Dyson 1.7744
1.3064
(113.9)
1.2555
(123.5)
1.3471
(108.5)
1.2654
(119.4)
Max Scherzer 0.9020
1.0659
(151.2)
1.0426
(143.8)
1.0638
(133.9)
1.0680
(168.3)
Johnny Cueto 1.4457
1.1683
(160.3)
1.1216
(181.6)
1.2100
(146.3)
1.1268
(174.4)
Matt Moore 1.5315
1.2972
(161.5)
1.3273
(126.8)
1.2671
(201.1)
1.3280
(121.5)
Craig Kimbrel 0.6812
1.1783
(133.9)
1.1672
(134.6)
1.1678
(126.1)
1.1890
(141.6)
Kevin Gausman 1.4946
1.2870
(145.0)
1.2781
(141.0)
1.2732
(172.6)
1.3011
(117.3)
Jameson Taillon 1.4813
1.2260
(132.3)
1.2105
(133.3)
1.2148
(150.6)
1.2374
(114.0)

Individual Misses for WHIP

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Zack Greinke 1.2133 1.0725 136.7
2 Ryan Madson 1.3014 0.7966 117.1
3 Robbie Ray 1.2947 1.1543 113.3
4 James Paxton 1.2714 1.1029 109.5
5 Sonny Gray 1.3339 1.2074 106.0
6 David Robertson 1.2142 0.8488 104.4
7 Michael Fulmer 1.2782 1.1538 104.3

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Robbie Ray 1.4065 1.1543 196.8
2 Marco Estrada 1.1477 1.3817 153.3
3 James Paxton 1.3208 1.1029 144.4
4 Stephen Strasburg 1.1528 1.0152 127.1
5 Julio Teheran 1.1738 1.3699 123.7
6 Jharel Cotton 1.1895 1.4419 118.0
7 Jeff Samardzija 1.2293 1.1364 115.7

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Zack Greinke 1.2488 1.0725 149.1
2 Ryan Madson 1.3265 0.7966 118.2
3 Sonny Gray 1.3684 1.2074 115.9
4 David Robertson 1.2418 0.8488 106.4
5 Adam Wainwright 1.2981 1.5000 104.8
6 Jeff Samardzija 1.2499 1.1364 104.5
7 Michael Fulmer 1.2957 1.1538 102.6

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Robbie Ray 1.3214 1.1543 144.2
2 James Paxton 1.3014 1.1029 137.0
3 Marco Estrada 1.1701 1.3817 130.5
4 Zack Greinke 1.1780 1.0725 124.4
5 Ryan Madson 1.2761 0.7966 115.9
6 Yu Darvish 1.2560 1.1625 109.7
7 Michael Fulmer 1.2604 1.1538 105.7

Most Unique Misses for WHIP

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Robbie Ray 1.4065 1.2947 1.1543 196.8 113.3 83.6
2 Marco Estrada 1.1477 1.2548 1.3817 153.3 78.2 75.1
3 Jake Arrieta 1.0526 1.1724 1.2178 85.8 11.0 74.9
4 Jharel Cotton 1.1895 1.3124 1.4419 118.0 56.3 61.7
5 Aaron Nola 1.2835 1.2098 1.2083 82.4 21.7 60.7
6 Tanner Roark 1.2092 1.3098 1.3346 63.3 4.0 59.3
7 Drew Pomeranz 1.2119 1.2948 1.3532 72.2 21.1 51.1
8 Masahiro Tanaka 1.1073 1.1829 1.2393 66.3 19.9 46.4
9 Stephen Strasburg 1.1528 1.1115 1.0152 127.1 88.5 38.6
10 James Paxton 1.3208 1.2714 1.1029 144.4 109.5 34.9

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Matt Moore 1.2671 1.2972 1.5315 201.1 161.5 39.5
2 Kevin Gausman 1.2732 1.2870 1.4946 172.6 145.0 27.6
3 Kyle Hendricks 1.2329 1.1710 1.1885 30.9 7.1 23.8
4 Tanner Roark 1.3601 1.3098 1.3346 27.5 4.0 23.5
5 Jake Arrieta 1.2505 1.1724 1.2178 30.1 11.0 19.1
6 Jameson Taillon 1.2148 1.2260 1.4813 150.6 132.3 18.3
7 Chris Archer 1.1921 1.1899 1.2587 48.3 33.1 15.2
8 Michael Pineda 1.1607 1.1738 1.2872 47.8 34.2 13.6
9 Jeff Samardzija 1.2499 1.2143 1.1364 104.5 91.3 13.2
10 Chris Sale 1.1264 1.0916 0.9705 141.2 128.6 12.6

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Marco Estrada 1.1701 1.2548 1.3817 130.5 78.2 52.3
2 Yu Darvish 1.2560 1.2186 1.1625 109.7 65.9 43.9
3 Jake Arrieta 1.0957 1.1724 1.2178 51.1 11.0 40.2
4 Robbie Ray 1.3214 1.2947 1.1543 144.2 113.3 30.9
5 James Paxton 1.3014 1.2714 1.1029 137.0 109.5 27.5
6 Sean Manaea 1.2466 1.2993 1.3992 71.1 48.4 22.8
7 John Lackey 1.1547 1.1990 1.2773 53.3 35.4 17.8
8 Max Scherzer 1.0680 1.0659 0.9020 168.3 151.2 17.2
9 Ian Kennedy 1.3043 1.2991 1.3247 19.3 2.8 16.4
10 Jon Lester 1.0914 1.1322 1.3229 138.6 122.7 16.0