2016 Fantasy Projection Evaluation

Fantasy-relevant accuracy for 2016, limited to the top 250 players by FantasyPros's preseason ADP aggregate. Limited to 5x5 categories, with playing time (PA/BF) split out from rates.

Summary

Batting

System PA HR SB R RBI AVG
ATC
Aggregate
Depth Charts
Marcel
OOPSY
Razzball
Steamer
The BAT
The BAT X
ZiPS

Pitching

System BF SO W SV ERA WHIP
ATC
Aggregate
Depth Charts
Marcel
OOPSY
Razzball
Steamer
The BAT
The BAT X
ZiPS

Batting Projection Accuracy

Plate Appearances (PA)

Everybody Missed for Plate Appearances (PA)

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Michael Brantley 43
525
(482.0)
566
(523.0)
436
(392.9)
614
(571.0)
AJ Pollock 46
467
(421.4)
565
(519.0)
400
(353.8)
535
(489.0)
Kyle Schwarber 5
561
(556.5)
349
(344.0)
537
(531.9)
586
(581.0)
Shin-Soo Choo 210
591
(381.1)
571
(361.0)
608
(398.3)
574
(364.0)
Dee Strange-Gordon 346
620
(274.1)
595
(249.0)
634
(288.2)
606
(260.0)
David Peralta 183
568
(385.3)
493
(310.0)
587
(403.6)
550
(367.0)
Mike Moustakas 113
575
(462.2)
560
(447.0)
574
(460.5)
577
(464.0)
Lucas Duda 172
543
(371.4)
535
(363.0)
545
(372.7)
542
(370.0)
Delino DeShields 203
563
(359.6)
459
(256.0)
593
(390.3)
532
(329.0)
Blake Swihart 74
385
(311.1)
365
(291.0)
338
(264.1)
432
(358.0)

Individual Misses for Plate Appearances (PA)

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 ByungHo Park 572 244 328.0
2 David Wright 452 164 288.4
3 Billy Burns 615 332 282.6
4 Devin Mesoraco 320 55 264.9
5 Prince Fielder 619 370 248.9
6 Michael Conforto 572 348 224.1
7 Matt Duffy 580 366 214.4
8 Kolten Wong 572 361 211.2
9 Ben Revere 586 375 210.8
10 Justin Turner 416 622 206.2

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Corey Seager 267 687 420.0
2 Trevor Story 100 415 315.0
3 Stephen Piscotty 336 649 313.0
4 Wil Myers 369 676 307.0
5 George Springer 466 744 278.0
6 Francisco Lindor 434 684 250.0
7 Maikel Franco 384 630 246.0
8 José Reyes 519 279 240.0
9 Denard Span 401 637 236.0
10 Dustin Pedroia 468 698 230.0

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Devin Mesoraco 399 55 343.9
2 Billy Burns 630 332 298.2
3 ByungHo Park 531 244 286.9
4 David Wright 431 164 266.7
5 Prince Fielder 635 370 264.8
6 Matt Duffy 588 366 221.8
7 Kolten Wong 574 361 212.5
8 Ben Revere 586 375 210.6
9 Yasiel Puig 575 368 206.7
10 Jorge Soler 464 264 200.5

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 ByungHo Park 613 244 369.0
2 David Wright 474 164 310.0
3 Justin Turner 345 622 277.0
4 Billy Burns 599 332 267.0
5 José Reyes 545 279 266.0
6 Michael Conforto 610 348 262.0
7 George Springer 503 744 241.0
8 Wil Myers 443 676 233.0
9 Prince Fielder 603 370 233.0
10 Jonathan Schoop 429 647 218.0

Most Unique Misses for Plate Appearances (PA)

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Corey Seager 267 608 687 420.0 79.0 341.0
2 Trevor Story 100 438 415 315.0 22.6 292.4
3 Francisco Lindor 434 662 684 250.0 22.4 227.6
4 Stephen Piscotty 336 561 649 313.0 88.0 225.0
5 Maikel Franco 384 565 630 246.0 64.6 181.4
6 José Reyes 519 339 279 240.0 60.2 179.8
7 Carlos Correa 433 596 660 227.0 64.0 163.0
8 Wil Myers 369 500 676 307.0 175.8 131.2
9 Denard Span 401 527 637 236.0 110.1 125.9
10 Mookie Betts 565 677 730 165.0 53.4 111.6

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 José Reyes 134 339 279 145.5 60.2 85.2
2 Devin Mesoraco 399 320 55 343.9 264.9 78.9
3 Trevor Story 332 438 415 82.7 22.6 60.1
4 Hunter Pence 603 544 442 161.2 102.1 59.1
5 Jean Segura 507 558 694 186.7 136.4 50.4
6 Josh Harrison 577 528 522 54.7 6.4 48.4
7 Starlin Castro 556 598 610 53.8 12.4 41.4
8 Jorge Soler 464 425 264 200.5 160.8 39.8
9 Daniel Murphy 534 570 582 48.4 12.2 36.2
10 Matt Holliday 511 475 426 85.3 49.1 36.1

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 José Reyes 545 339 279 266.0 60.2 205.8
2 Trevor Story 543 438 415 128.0 22.6 105.4
3 Michael Brantley 614 525 43 571.0 482.0 89.0
4 Justin Turner 345 416 622 277.0 206.2 70.8
5 Logan Forsythe 449 518 567 118.0 49.0 69.0
6 AJ Pollock 535 467 46 489.0 421.4 67.6
7 Curtis Granderson 520 581 633 113.0 52.5 60.5
8 Mark Teixeira 350 408 438 88.0 29.9 58.1
9 Wil Myers 443 500 676 233.0 175.8 57.2
10 Mitch Moreland 412 463 503 91.0 39.9 51.1

Home Run Rate

Everybody Missed for Home Run Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Khris Davis 0.1066
0.0591
(23.9)
0.0690
(16.7)
0.0620
(21.9)
0.0561
(26.0)
Robinson Canó 0.0696
0.0351
(18.8)
0.0371
(16.0)
0.0362
(17.7)
0.0340
(19.9)
Brett Gardner 0.0156
0.0317
(15.4)
0.0322
(17.0)
0.0315
(15.6)
0.0318
(15.3)
Jason Heyward 0.0159
0.0382
(18.1)
0.0306
(14.7)
0.0380
(18.2)
0.0385
(18.0)
Carlos González 0.0548
0.0787
(20.3)
0.0769
(20.4)
0.0748
(18.1)
0.0826
(22.5)
Todd Frazier 0.0920
0.0575
(17.4)
0.0587
(15.4)
0.0580
(16.8)
0.0571
(18.0)
Bryce Harper 0.0602
0.0894
(23.5)
0.0720
(13.8)
0.0848
(20.9)
0.0942
(26.2)
Trevor Story 0.1102
0.0478
(22.5)
0.0540
(19.1)
0.0423
(24.6)
0.0537
(20.2)
Brian Dozier 0.0868
0.0478
(21.3)
0.0485
(19.4)
0.0429
(24.3)
0.0526
(18.2)
Paul Goldschmidt 0.0548
0.0727
(18.4)
0.0684
(16.8)
0.0734
(19.2)
0.0720
(17.6)
Ian Kinsler 0.0553
0.0245
(15.3)
0.0246
(13.9)
0.0262
(13.9)
0.0229
(16.7)
José Abreu 0.0492
0.0678
(18.6)
0.0644
(17.7)
0.0687
(19.6)
0.0668
(17.7)

Individual Misses for Home Run Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Mike Trout 0.0871 0.0695 17.5
2 George Springer 0.0766 0.0621 16.9
3 Mark Trumbo 0.0735 0.1061 16.2
4 Yasmani Grandal 0.0558 0.0982 15.6
5 Jonathan Lucroy 0.0267 0.0609 14.1
6 Mark Teixeira 0.0753 0.0528 13.5
7 Rougned Odor 0.0407 0.0696 13.1
8 Starling Marte 0.0395 0.0233 12.9

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Mark Trumbo 0.0580 0.1061 25.3
2 Yasmani Grandal 0.0510 0.0982 16.9
3 Freddie Freeman 0.0458 0.0804 16.9
4 Ketel Marte 0.0248 0.0028 15.0
5 Carlos Correa 0.0579 0.0454 15.0
6 Adrián González 0.0513 0.0394 14.0
7 Rougned Odor 0.0375 0.0696 13.8
8 Kole Calhoun 0.0474 0.0374 13.5

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Mark Trumbo 0.0697 0.1061 18.5
2 Mike Trout 0.0875 0.0695 18.1
3 Yasmani Grandal 0.0519 0.0982 17.2
4 George Springer 0.0731 0.0621 14.6
5 Rougned Odor 0.0385 0.0696 14.2
6 Adrián González 0.0526 0.0394 13.8
7 Daniel Murphy 0.0198 0.0519 13.6
8 Starling Marte 0.0398 0.0233 13.3

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 George Springer 0.0804 0.0621 19.4
2 Carlos Correa 0.0635 0.0454 17.1
3 Mike Trout 0.0867 0.0695 17.0
4 Jonathan Lucroy 0.0241 0.0609 15.8
5 J.D. Martinez 0.0873 0.0653 15.4
6 Matt Kemp 0.0432 0.0731 14.8
7 Hanley Ramirez 0.0381 0.0693 14.5
8 Chris Davis 0.1224 0.1086 14.4

Most Unique Misses for Home Run Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Kris Bryant 0.0583 0.0810 0.0863 12.5 2.1 10.4
2 Mark Trumbo 0.0580 0.0735 0.1061 25.3 16.2 9.1
3 Francisco Lindor 0.0366 0.0266 0.0281 12.8 4.6 8.2
4 Wil Myers 0.0400 0.0529 0.0631 8.7 1.3 7.4
5 Ketel Marte 0.0248 0.0118 0.0028 15.0 8.1 7.0
6 Manny Machado 0.0480 0.0579 0.0705 8.5 3.0 5.5
7 ByungHo Park 0.0540 0.0798 0.0870 5.6 0.3 5.3
8 J.T. Realmuto 0.0290 0.0214 0.0267 6.8 1.6 5.2
9 Freddie Freeman 0.0458 0.0540 0.0804 16.9 12.5 4.3
10 Billy Burns 0.0187 0.0078 0.0000 9.6 5.3 4.3

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 David Ortiz 0.0644 0.0725 0.0830 6.2 1.4 4.8
2 Brian Dozier 0.0429 0.0478 0.0868 24.3 21.3 3.1
3 Manny Machado 0.0530 0.0579 0.0705 6.1 3.0 3.1
4 Jacoby Ellsbury 0.0293 0.0255 0.0185 12.2 9.5 2.6
5 ByungHo Park 0.0892 0.0798 0.0870 2.7 0.3 2.4
6 Mark Trumbo 0.0697 0.0735 0.1061 18.5 16.2 2.3
7 Trevor Story 0.0423 0.0478 0.1102 24.6 22.5 2.1
8 Nelson Cruz 0.0757 0.0793 0.0984 9.3 7.2 2.1
9 Victor Martinez 0.0369 0.0405 0.0579 7.6 5.6 2.0
10 Kris Bryant 0.0834 0.0810 0.0863 4.0 2.1 1.9

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Carlos Correa 0.0635 0.0549 0.0454 17.1 11.7 5.4
2 J.D. Martinez 0.0873 0.0776 0.0653 15.4 10.6 4.8
3 Chris Davis 0.1224 0.1150 0.1086 14.4 9.7 4.7
4 Hanley Ramirez 0.0381 0.0449 0.0693 14.5 10.0 4.4
5 Matt Kemp 0.0432 0.0486 0.0731 14.8 10.9 3.9
6 Xander Bogaerts 0.0240 0.0279 0.0395 5.5 2.4 3.1
7 Bryce Harper 0.0942 0.0894 0.0602 26.2 23.5 2.7
8 George Springer 0.0804 0.0766 0.0621 19.4 16.9 2.5
9 Corey Dickerson 0.0601 0.0554 0.0633 2.5 0.2 2.3
10 Eric Hosmer 0.0327 0.0357 0.0524 7.9 5.7 2.3

Stolen Base Rate

Everybody Missed for Stolen Base Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Jacoby Ellsbury 0.1227
0.1797
(28.5)
0.2045
(44.9)
0.1734
(26.6)
0.1857
(30.3)
Brandon Belt 0.0000
0.0553
(28.7)
0.0560
(30.1)
0.0523
(28.8)
0.0583
(28.6)
Manny Machado 0.0000
0.0931
(56.9)
0.0728
(43.7)
0.0858
(53.9)
0.1000
(59.4)
Derek Norris 0.1047
0.0329
(38.1)
0.0385
(34.9)
0.0301
(37.9)
0.0357
(38.3)
Matt Kemp 0.0077
0.0663
(31.7)
0.0741
(37.8)
0.0618
(30.8)
0.0709
(32.6)
Starling Marte 0.3287
0.1943
(77.1)
0.1986
(74.1)
0.1732
(86.6)
0.2157
(67.5)
Mike Trout 0.1282
0.0863
(36.3)
0.0852
(36.1)
0.0764
(40.9)
0.0964
(31.6)
Jose Altuve 0.1415
0.2083
(39.7)
0.2083
(40.7)
0.2015
(37.1)
0.2151
(42.2)
Charlie Blackmon 0.0977
0.1918
(53.0)
0.1842
(49.0)
0.1985
(59.3)
0.1852
(46.7)
Paul Goldschmidt 0.1397
0.0802
(50.0)
0.0800
(49.2)
0.0711
(54.2)
0.0894
(45.8)
Bryce Harper 0.1141
0.0318
(58.8)
0.0407
(52.4)
0.0369
(53.6)
0.0269
(63.9)
Wil Myers 0.1687
0.0707
(74.0)
0.0667
(75.8)
0.0679
(73.7)
0.0734
(74.3)
DJ LeMahieu 0.0524
0.1133
(31.4)
0.1090
(29.5)
0.1041
(27.6)
0.1227
(35.4)

Individual Misses for Stolen Base Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 George Springer 0.1193 0.0441 47.4
2 Carlos Correa 0.1502 0.0726 43.7
3 Rougned Odor 0.0768 0.1197 34.3
4 Christian Yelich 0.1035 0.0484 28.8
5 Ender Inciarte 0.1570 0.0958 28.7
6 Brian Dozier 0.0905 0.1184 27.2
7 Anthony Rendon 0.0427 0.0727 26.8

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Rougned Odor 0.0536 0.1197 48.1
2 Billy Hamilton 0.4052 0.4874 42.5
3 Byron Buxton 0.0678 0.1724 38.0
4 Denard Span 0.1308 0.0706 32.0
5 Josh Harrison 0.1034 0.1520 30.6
6 Billy Burns 0.1484 0.2297 30.3
7 Hunter Pence 0.0870 0.0083 30.3

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 George Springer 0.1049 0.0441 39.1
2 Carlos Correa 0.1285 0.0726 31.4
3 Billy Hamilton 0.4282 0.4874 31.0
4 Brian Dozier 0.0853 0.1184 28.6
5 Christian Yelich 0.0980 0.0484 27.2
6 Anthony Rendon 0.0403 0.0727 26.3
7 Denard Span 0.1188 0.0706 25.5

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Carlos Correa 0.1729 0.0726 56.5
2 George Springer 0.1339 0.0441 55.9
3 Rougned Odor 0.0647 0.1197 43.9
4 Ender Inciarte 0.1699 0.0958 34.4
5 Carlos González 0.0762 0.0132 30.6
6 Christian Yelich 0.1091 0.0484 30.4
7 Anthony Rendon 0.0451 0.0727 27.3

Most Unique Misses for Stolen Base Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Byron Buxton 0.0678 0.1660 0.1724 38.0 5.9 32.1
2 Mookie Betts 0.1159 0.1449 0.1390 24.2 4.1 20.1
3 Billy Burns 0.1484 0.2058 0.2297 30.3 11.7 18.6
4 Billy Hamilton 0.4052 0.4437 0.4874 42.5 25.3 17.1
5 Jacoby Ellsbury 0.2045 0.1797 0.1227 44.9 28.5 16.4
6 Corey Seager 0.0580 0.0355 0.0167 21.5 5.1 16.4
7 Rougned Odor 0.0536 0.0768 0.1197 48.1 34.3 13.8
8 Andrew McCutchen 0.0829 0.0654 0.0345 25.9 13.1 12.7
9 J.T. Realmuto 0.0714 0.0920 0.0828 11.7 1.2 10.5
10 Carlos González 0.0684 0.0536 0.0132 28.5 18.3 10.2

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Starling Marte 0.1732 0.1943 0.3287 86.6 77.1 9.5
2 Nolan Arenado 0.0322 0.0245 0.0118 8.5 0.9 7.5
3 Charlie Blackmon 0.1985 0.1918 0.0977 59.3 53.0 6.3
4 Billy Hamilton 0.4282 0.4437 0.4874 31.0 25.3 5.7
5 Jean Segura 0.1612 0.1719 0.1774 17.0 11.8 5.2
6 Jonathan Schoop 0.0308 0.0266 0.0078 9.6 4.8 4.8
7 Mike Trout 0.0764 0.0863 0.1282 40.9 36.3 4.6
8 Ian Desmond 0.0996 0.1090 0.1214 20.4 16.1 4.2
9 Paul Goldschmidt 0.0711 0.0802 0.1397 54.2 50.0 4.2
10 Addison Russell 0.0714 0.0676 0.0350 16.9 12.7 4.2

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Carlos Correa 0.1729 0.1502 0.0726 56.5 43.7 12.9
2 Carlos González 0.0762 0.0536 0.0132 30.6 18.3 12.2
3 Rougned Odor 0.0647 0.0768 0.1197 43.9 34.3 9.6
4 George Springer 0.1339 0.1193 0.0441 55.9 47.4 8.5
5 Hanley Ramirez 0.0952 0.0796 0.0545 16.2 8.5 7.7
6 Jason Kipnis 0.1220 0.1088 0.0904 11.7 4.8 6.9
7 Nolan Arenado 0.0161 0.0245 0.0118 7.1 0.9 6.2
8 Kevin Pillar 0.1618 0.1483 0.1061 24.0 18.0 6.0
9 Brett Gardner 0.1250 0.1125 0.0860 15.4 9.5 5.9
10 Trevor Story 0.1504 0.1332 0.0899 19.1 13.2 5.8

Run Rate

Everybody Missed for Run Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Jason Heyward 0.1030
0.1367
(24.7)
0.1248
(17.4)
0.1347
(24.4)
0.1387
(25.0)
Xander Bogaerts 0.1599
0.1180
(24.4)
0.1159
(26.2)
0.1223
(20.2)
0.1137
(28.6)
Kris Bryant 0.1731
0.1394
(18.0)
0.1275
(26.5)
0.1359
(19.4)
0.1429
(16.6)
Alcides Escobar 0.0836
0.1080
(22.1)
0.1100
(23.2)
0.1039
(20.3)
0.1121
(23.9)
Ian Desmond 0.1581
0.1097
(27.3)
0.1117
(26.2)
0.1077
(27.7)
0.1118
(26.9)
Nolan Arenado 0.1667
0.1231
(24.7)
0.1248
(23.8)
0.1319
(17.6)
0.1144
(31.8)
Jean Segura 0.1470
0.1034
(24.7)
0.1075
(22.1)
0.0982
(27.3)
0.1086
(22.1)
Charlie Blackmon 0.1732
0.1235
(26.7)
0.1291
(23.3)
0.1326
(19.9)
0.1144
(33.5)
Ian Kinsler 0.1723
0.1287
(24.2)
0.1348
(20.3)
0.1245
(26.0)
0.1328
(22.4)
José Abreu 0.0964
0.1340
(31.7)
0.1275
(26.9)
0.1305
(30.2)
0.1375
(33.1)
DJ LeMahieu 0.1638
0.1076
(30.6)
0.1182
(24.1)
0.1106
(27.8)
0.1046
(33.5)

Individual Misses for Run Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Trevor Story 0.1069 0.1614 19.3
2 Corey Seager 0.1177 0.1528 18.6
3 Bryce Harper 0.1555 0.1340 18.5
4 Dustin Pedroia 0.1160 0.1504 18.4
5 Josh Donaldson 0.1405 0.1743 18.0
6 Troy Tulowitzki 0.1240 0.0993 17.8
7 Francisco Lindor 0.1109 0.1447 17.7
8 Carlos Gómez 0.1282 0.0993 16.7
9 Giancarlo Stanton 0.1465 0.1191 16.6

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Troy Tulowitzki 0.1480 0.0993 30.7
2 Corey Dickerson 0.1382 0.1040 22.9
3 Jose Altuve 0.1150 0.1506 20.1
4 Carlos Gómez 0.1340 0.0993 19.2
5 Dustin Pedroia 0.1154 0.1504 19.1
6 George Springer 0.1245 0.1559 17.7
7 Robinson Canó 0.1178 0.1497 17.3
8 Mookie Betts 0.1363 0.1671 16.9
9 Rougned Odor 0.1066 0.1408 16.8

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Corey Seager 0.1110 0.1528 22.2
2 Prince Fielder 0.1289 0.0784 22.2
3 Troy Tulowitzki 0.1256 0.0993 19.5
4 Giancarlo Stanton 0.1486 0.1191 18.3
5 Trevor Story 0.1088 0.1614 17.9
6 Ender Inciarte 0.1068 0.1471 17.8
7 Robinson Canó 0.1172 0.1497 16.4
8 Andrew McCutchen 0.1346 0.1200 16.2
9 Bryce Harper 0.1503 0.1340 16.2

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Dustin Pedroia 0.1071 0.1504 25.6
2 Francisco Lindor 0.1060 0.1447 22.0
3 Bryce Harper 0.1606 0.1340 20.8
4 Trevor Story 0.1050 0.1614 20.7
5 Josh Donaldson 0.1385 0.1743 20.5
6 Maikel Franco 0.1304 0.1063 19.2
7 Carlos Gómez 0.1328 0.0993 18.1
8 Mookie Betts 0.1367 0.1671 17.4
9 Robinson Canó 0.1201 0.1497 16.4

Most Unique Misses for Run Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Troy Tulowitzki 0.1480 0.1240 0.0993 30.7 17.8 12.9
2 Corey Dickerson 0.1382 0.1145 0.1040 22.9 10.1 12.8
3 George Springer 0.1245 0.1379 0.1559 17.7 7.4 10.3
4 Jose Altuve 0.1150 0.1288 0.1506 20.1 9.9 10.1
5 Kris Bryant 0.1275 0.1394 0.1731 26.5 18.0 8.5
6 Rougned Odor 0.1066 0.1189 0.1408 16.8 8.8 8.0
7 Mike Trout 0.1502 0.1600 0.1806 15.5 8.6 6.9
8 Mark Trumbo 0.1144 0.1232 0.1409 12.6 6.5 6.1
9 Hanley Ramirez 0.1345 0.1246 0.1306 7.1 1.2 5.9
10 Joc Pederson 0.1096 0.1210 0.1345 8.2 2.6 5.6

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 David Ortiz 0.1370 0.1179 0.1262 12.7 0.2 12.5
2 Victor Martinez 0.1193 0.1099 0.1066 13.5 6.9 6.6
3 Miguel Cabrera 0.1418 0.1336 0.1355 10.7 4.1 6.5
4 Wil Myers 0.1137 0.1246 0.1464 15.7 9.4 6.4
5 Freddie Freeman 0.1224 0.1325 0.1472 10.6 4.6 6.0
6 Prince Fielder 0.1289 0.1142 0.0784 22.2 16.2 6.0
7 J.T. Realmuto 0.0890 0.0999 0.1101 6.4 1.2 5.2
8 Yadier Molina 0.0954 0.0890 0.0964 4.9 0.3 4.6
9 Mitch Moreland 0.1141 0.1068 0.0974 13.1 8.7 4.4
10 Hunter Pence 0.1115 0.1238 0.1312 4.5 0.3 4.3

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 David Ortiz 0.0989 0.1179 0.1262 13.0 0.2 12.9
2 Dustin Pedroia 0.1071 0.1160 0.1504 25.6 18.4 7.2
3 Nolan Arenado 0.1144 0.1231 0.1667 31.8 24.7 7.1
4 Charlie Blackmon 0.1144 0.1235 0.1732 33.5 26.7 6.8
5 Yoenis Cespedes 0.1415 0.1280 0.1326 8.4 1.8 6.5
6 Jose Altuve 0.1227 0.1288 0.1506 15.4 9.9 5.5
7 Carlos Santana 0.1098 0.1161 0.1294 8.9 3.7 5.3
8 Brandon Belt 0.1299 0.1210 0.1176 12.4 7.5 4.9
9 Michael Conforto 0.1393 0.1239 0.1092 12.8 7.9 4.9
10 Hunter Pence 0.1361 0.1238 0.1312 5.0 0.3 4.8

RBI Rate

Everybody Missed for RBI Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Brett Gardner 0.0647
0.0971
(23.9)
0.0957
(25.5)
0.0956
(24.2)
0.0987
(23.6)
Daniel Murphy 0.1787
0.1157
(33.6)
0.1113
(33.9)
0.1092
(36.2)
0.1221
(31.1)
Addison Russell 0.1589
0.1143
(23.5)
0.1040
(27.4)
0.1106
(24.5)
0.1180
(22.5)
Gregory Polanco 0.1465
0.0964
(26.3)
0.0911
(27.2)
0.0924
(27.5)
0.1005
(25.1)
Brian Dozier 0.1433
0.1049
(22.9)
0.1059
(19.5)
0.1020
(23.5)
0.1079
(22.3)
Mark Teixeira 0.1005
0.1623
(29.4)
0.1398
(21.2)
0.1418
(21.3)
0.1829
(37.5)
Jose Altuve 0.1339
0.0924
(26.0)
0.0895
(25.3)
0.0925
(24.5)
0.0924
(27.5)
Christian Yelich 0.1487
0.0901
(35.2)
0.0832
(37.2)
0.0946
(30.9)
0.0856
(39.5)
Chris Davis 0.1263
0.1704
(32.8)
0.1621
(29.9)
0.1572
(25.4)
0.1835
(40.2)
Mookie Betts 0.1548
0.1135
(26.3)
0.1097
(26.2)
0.1119
(26.0)
0.1151
(26.6)

Individual Misses for RBI Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Nolan Arenado 0.1492 0.1911 25.5
2 Ryan Zimmerman 0.1472 0.0985 25.2
3 Travis d'Arnaud 0.1342 0.0543 23.5
4 Josh Reddick 0.1306 0.0843 22.6
5 Trevor Story 0.1142 0.1735 22.4
6 David Ortiz 0.1619 0.2029 22.4
7 Hanley Ramirez 0.1411 0.1790 20.3
8 Billy Hamilton 0.0751 0.0370 20.0
9 Jonathan Lucroy 0.1088 0.1489 19.0
10 Khris Davis 0.1311 0.1672 18.8

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Ryan Zimmerman 0.1470 0.0985 26.9
2 Danny Valencia 0.1353 0.0986 23.7
3 Nolan Arenado 0.1484 0.1911 23.4
4 Hanley Ramirez 0.1323 0.1790 23.3
5 Josh Reddick 0.1281 0.0843 23.2
6 Billy Hamilton 0.0765 0.0370 22.4
7 Ender Inciarte 0.0785 0.0502 21.7
8 Alex Gordon 0.1125 0.0791 21.6
9 Albert Pujols 0.1414 0.1831 21.2
10 Joc Pederson 0.0920 0.1429 19.9

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 David Ortiz 0.1546 0.2029 25.6
2 Josh Reddick 0.1313 0.0843 23.8
3 Trevor Story 0.1124 0.1735 22.3
4 Travis d'Arnaud 0.1266 0.0543 21.9
5 Jonathan Lucroy 0.1032 0.1489 20.9
6 Billy Hamilton 0.0747 0.0370 20.7
7 George Springer 0.1307 0.1102 20.6
8 Alex Gordon 0.1113 0.0791 20.0
9 Jason Heyward 0.1082 0.0828 19.4
10 Starling Marte 0.1162 0.0870 19.3

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Nolan Arenado 0.1422 0.1911 31.8
2 Ryan Zimmerman 0.1620 0.0985 31.1
3 Travis d'Arnaud 0.1418 0.0543 25.0
4 Brian McCann 0.1649 0.1179 24.7
5 Corey Seager 0.1353 0.1048 23.2
6 Trevor Story 0.1160 0.1735 22.5
7 Hanley Ramirez 0.1396 0.1790 22.5
8 José Bautista 0.1736 0.1335 22.4
9 Danny Valencia 0.1380 0.0986 22.0
10 Khris Davis 0.1283 0.1672 21.8

Most Unique Misses for RBI Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Anthony Rizzo 0.1276 0.1495 0.1612 16.5 4.4 12.2
2 Mark Trumbo 0.1341 0.1526 0.1619 12.4 2.7 9.8
3 Manny Machado 0.1082 0.1251 0.1379 14.3 5.3 9.1
4 Brandon Phillips 0.1198 0.1095 0.1096 11.3 3.0 8.3
5 Jonathan Schoop 0.1053 0.1206 0.1267 8.0 0.6 7.4
6 Joc Pederson 0.0920 0.1108 0.1429 19.9 12.8 7.1
7 Miguel Cabrera 0.1602 0.1542 0.1591 7.0 0.2 6.8
8 Marcus Semien 0.0897 0.1043 0.1208 13.6 7.0 6.6
9 Matt Duffy 0.1200 0.1065 0.0765 19.3 12.9 6.4
10 Billy Burns 0.0847 0.0698 0.0392 18.2 11.9 6.2

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Mark Trumbo 0.1383 0.1526 0.1619 10.9 2.7 8.2
2 Bryce Harper 0.1577 0.1471 0.1372 17.4 9.5 7.9
3 Mike Trout 0.1610 0.1539 0.1468 14.6 8.4 6.2
4 Gerardo Parra 0.1130 0.1010 0.1024 6.8 1.5 5.3
5 Russell Martin 0.1169 0.1284 0.1383 7.6 2.5 5.1
6 Brandon Crawford 0.1025 0.1127 0.1348 15.6 10.5 5.1
7 Brandon Belt 0.1258 0.1206 0.1252 5.2 0.5 4.7
8 Dustin Pedroia 0.1054 0.1006 0.1060 4.7 0.1 4.6
9 Ryan Braun 0.1346 0.1446 0.1613 11.0 6.5 4.5
10 Matt Kemp 0.1263 0.1350 0.1607 18.2 13.8 4.4

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Mark Teixeira 0.1829 0.1623 0.1005 37.5 29.4 8.1
2 Carlos Correa 0.1583 0.1448 0.1455 10.6 3.0 7.6
3 Chris Davis 0.1835 0.1704 0.1263 40.2 32.8 7.4
4 Victor Martinez 0.1590 0.1448 0.1410 12.9 5.5 7.4
5 Adrián González 0.1625 0.1492 0.1422 14.9 7.8 7.1
6 Brian McCann 0.1649 0.1489 0.1179 24.7 17.8 6.9
7 Corey Seager 0.1353 0.1237 0.1048 23.2 16.6 6.6
8 Nolan Arenado 0.1422 0.1492 0.1911 31.8 25.5 6.3
9 Josh Donaldson 0.1615 0.1508 0.1414 16.3 10.2 6.1
10 Corey Dickerson 0.1106 0.1195 0.1277 7.6 1.6 6.0

Batting Average

Everybody Missed for Batting Average

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Ben Revere 0.2171
0.3003
(32.0)
0.2980
(30.4)
0.2998
(31.9)
0.3007
(32.1)
Alex Gordon 0.2202
0.2660
(24.3)
0.2663
(23.4)
0.2707
(26.8)
0.2612
(21.7)
Dustin Pedroia 0.3175
0.2804
(24.3)
0.2840
(23.3)
0.2817
(23.3)
0.2792
(25.4)
Daniel Murphy 0.3465
0.2945
(29.0)
0.2805
(38.3)
0.3042
(23.2)
0.2850
(34.7)
Jason Heyward 0.2302
0.2765
(28.8)
0.2734
(25.7)
0.2787
(30.2)
0.2744
(27.3)
Derek Norris 0.1855
0.2435
(27.6)
0.2553
(32.0)
0.2400
(26.1)
0.2470
(29.1)
J.T. Realmuto 0.3026
0.2537
(25.4)
0.2572
(24.6)
0.2557
(24.2)
0.2517
(26.7)
Jean Segura 0.3187
0.2687
(33.2)
0.2625
(38.9)
0.2703
(31.8)
0.2670
(34.5)
Charlie Blackmon 0.3235
0.2830
(24.6)
0.2836
(25.5)
0.2807
(25.8)
0.2852
(23.3)
David Ortiz 0.3147
0.2690
(27.2)
0.2743
(25.2)
0.2742
(23.8)
0.2637
(30.7)
Yan Gomes 0.1673
0.2537
(23.4)
0.2621
(25.1)
0.2511
(22.8)
0.2563
(24.0)
Prince Fielder 0.2117
0.2809
(26.4)
0.2840
(26.8)
0.2909
(30.3)
0.2708
(22.6)
Andrew McCutchen 0.2559
0.2946
(27.7)
0.2971
(27.9)
0.2965
(29.1)
0.2927
(26.2)
Bryce Harper 0.2431
0.3056
(40.6)
0.2921
(30.8)
0.3005
(37.6)
0.3108
(43.7)
DJ LeMahieu 0.3478
0.2874
(36.9)
0.2819
(41.8)
0.2881
(36.3)
0.2868
(37.5)

Individual Misses for Batting Average

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Corey Seager 0.2640 0.3078 28.6
2 Joey Votto 0.2849 0.3255 26.0
3 Ian Desmond 0.2446 0.2848 25.7
4 Chris Davis 0.2556 0.2208 24.6
5 Joe Panik 0.2774 0.2392 21.3

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Joe Panik 0.2941 0.2392 28.9
2 Mookie Betts 0.2832 0.3185 25.6
3 Corey Dickerson 0.2882 0.2451 23.7
4 Elvis Andrus 0.2620 0.3024 22.9
5 Troy Tulowitzki 0.2941 0.2541 21.9

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Corey Seager 0.2624 0.3078 29.5
2 Ian Desmond 0.2428 0.2848 26.8
3 Joey Votto 0.2841 0.3255 26.3
4 Ryan Zimmerman 0.2625 0.2178 22.1
5 Joe Panik 0.2782 0.2392 21.8

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Chris Davis 0.2654 0.2208 30.9
2 Corey Seager 0.2655 0.3078 27.7
3 Joey Votto 0.2857 0.3255 25.6
4 Ian Desmond 0.2465 0.2848 24.6
5 Todd Frazier 0.2553 0.2254 21.2

Most Unique Misses for Batting Average

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Troy Tulowitzki 0.2941 0.2586 0.2541 21.9 3.7 18.2
2 Corey Dickerson 0.2882 0.2610 0.2451 23.7 10.0 13.8
3 Mookie Betts 0.2832 0.2977 0.3185 25.6 13.5 12.1
4 Daniel Murphy 0.2805 0.2945 0.3465 38.3 29.0 9.4
5 Jonathan Schoop 0.2449 0.2561 0.2667 14.0 5.4 8.6
6 Nolan Arenado 0.2787 0.2888 0.2945 10.9 2.4 8.5
7 Xander Bogaerts 0.2811 0.2902 0.2945 9.5 1.5 8.0
8 Joe Panik 0.2941 0.2774 0.2392 28.9 21.3 7.7
9 Russell Martin 0.2518 0.2354 0.2308 11.3 3.7 7.6
10 Jung Ho Kang 0.2762 0.2570 0.2547 8.0 1.7 6.3

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Nelson Cruz 0.2520 0.2584 0.2869 21.6 17.5 4.1
2 Prince Fielder 0.2909 0.2809 0.2117 30.3 26.4 3.8
3 Jonathan Schoop 0.2504 0.2561 0.2667 8.9 5.4 3.5
4 Yoenis Cespedes 0.2562 0.2629 0.2797 11.4 7.9 3.5
5 Marcus Semien 0.2540 0.2488 0.2377 11.7 8.3 3.4
6 Ian Kinsler 0.2679 0.2727 0.2880 11.9 8.9 3.1
7 J.D. Martinez 0.2718 0.2771 0.3065 16.6 14.0 2.6
8 Gregory Polanco 0.2617 0.2576 0.2581 3.6 1.0 2.6
9 Alex Gordon 0.2707 0.2660 0.2202 26.8 24.3 2.5
10 Anthony Rendon 0.2768 0.2734 0.2698 6.1 3.7 2.4

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Justin Turner 0.2945 0.2838 0.2752 13.2 6.8 6.5
2 Chris Davis 0.2654 0.2556 0.2208 30.9 24.6 6.3
3 Daniel Murphy 0.2850 0.2945 0.3465 34.7 29.0 5.7
4 Mike Trout 0.2944 0.3004 0.3151 12.8 8.5 4.2
5 Christian Yelich 0.2763 0.2820 0.2976 12.7 8.8 4.0
6 George Springer 0.2477 0.2527 0.2609 8.3 4.4 3.9
7 Khris Davis 0.2354 0.2412 0.2468 5.8 2.1 3.7
8 David Ortiz 0.2637 0.2690 0.3147 30.7 27.2 3.5
9 Victor Martinez 0.2790 0.2841 0.2893 5.1 1.8 3.3
10 Bryce Harper 0.3108 0.3056 0.2431 43.7 40.6 3.1

Pitching Projection Accuracy

Batters Faced (BF)

Everybody Missed for Batters Faced (BF)

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Shelby Miller 460
799
(338.7)
770
(310.0)
802
(342.5)
795
(335.0)
Tyson Ross 27
779
(752.1)
727
(700.0)
793
(766.1)
765
(738.0)
Matt Harvey 402
764
(361.7)
631
(229.0)
827
(425.4)
700
(298.0)
Jaime García 741
440
(301.5)
524
(217.0)
488
(253.0)
391
(350.0)
Jordan Zimmermann 450
807
(356.5)
739
(289.0)
840
(390.1)
773
(323.0)
Alex Wood 255
694
(438.7)
703
(448.0)
663
(408.5)
724
(469.0)
Glen Perkins 12
249
(237.0)
246
(234.0)
270
(258.0)
228
(216.0)
Garrett Richards 148
798
(649.8)
732
(584.0)
826
(677.6)
770
(622.0)
Sonny Gray 517
883
(365.9)
766
(249.0)
879
(361.7)
887
(370.0)
Clayton Kershaw 544
850
(305.9)
767
(223.0)
855
(310.8)
845
(301.0)
Gerrit Cole 506
821
(315.1)
738
(232.0)
845
(339.2)
797
(291.0)

Individual Misses for Batters Faced (BF)

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Raisel Iglesias 662 325 336.6
2 Luis Severino 642 312 329.8
3 Aaron Nola 754 483 270.6
4 Lance McCullers Jr. 606 352 254.1
5 Wei-Yin Chen 771 520 251.3
6 Marcus Stroman 626 855 229.4
7 Drew Smyly 542 738 195.6
8 Félix Hernández 844 655 188.6
9 Hisashi Iwakuma 651 836 185.4

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Kenta Maeda 100 716 616.0
2 Marcus Stroman 337 855 518.0
3 Adam Wainwright 372 847 475.0
4 Drew Smyly 388 738 350.0
5 José Fernández 411 737 326.0
6 Justin Verlander 611 903 292.0
7 Hisashi Iwakuma 564 836 272.0
8 Patrick Corbin 435 701 266.0
9 Kevin Gausman 505 757 252.0

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Raisel Iglesias 751 325 426.2
2 Luis Severino 623 312 310.6
3 Wei-Yin Chen 813 520 292.5
4 Aaron Nola 761 483 278.1
5 Jacob deGrom 833 604 228.9
6 Kevin Gausman 549 757 208.3
7 Félix Hernández 858 655 203.2
8 Taijuan Walker 776 573 203.1
9 Lance McCullers Jr. 551 352 199.2

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Marcus Stroman 441 855 414.0
2 Luis Severino 661 312 349.0
3 Lance McCullers Jr. 661 352 309.0
4 Aaron Nola 746 483 263.0
5 Michael Pineda 507 756 249.0
6 Raisel Iglesias 572 325 247.0
7 Drew Smyly 497 738 241.0
8 Hisashi Iwakuma 608 836 228.0
9 Wei-Yin Chen 730 520 210.0

Most Unique Misses for Batters Faced (BF)

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Kenta Maeda 100 730 716 616.0 14.0 602.0
2 Adam Wainwright 372 726 847 475.0 120.6 354.4
3 Marcus Stroman 337 626 855 518.0 229.4 288.6
4 José Fernández 411 673 737 326.0 63.5 262.5
5 Patrick Corbin 435 610 701 266.0 90.6 175.4
6 Noah Syndergaard 570 736 744 174.0 8.4 165.6
7 Drew Smyly 388 542 738 350.0 195.6 154.4
8 Justin Verlander 611 763 903 292.0 139.9 152.1
9 Carlos Rodón 557 694 715 158.0 21.4 136.6
10 Carlos Martinez 605 733 809 204.0 75.8 128.2

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Raisel Iglesias 751 662 325 426.2 336.6 89.6
2 Clay Buchholz 716 631 588 127.9 42.9 84.9
3 Taijuan Walker 776 701 573 203.1 128.1 75.1
4 Matt Harvey 827 764 402 425.4 361.7 63.7
5 Kevin Gausman 549 606 757 208.3 150.6 57.6
6 Jacob deGrom 833 783 604 228.9 179.0 50.0
7 Kyle Hendricks 584 633 745 160.8 111.9 48.9
8 Jake Arrieta 850 806 795 55.2 10.6 44.6
9 Sean Doolittle 267 224 155 112.3 68.6 43.6
10 Michael Wacha 743 700 606 136.5 93.8 42.8

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Marcus Stroman 441 626 855 414.0 229.4 184.6
2 Adam Wainwright 650 726 847 197.0 120.6 76.4
3 Michael Pineda 507 573 756 249.0 183.4 65.6
4 José Fernández 609 673 737 128.0 63.5 64.5
5 Patrick Corbin 549 610 701 152.0 90.6 61.4
6 Justin Verlander 703 763 903 200.0 139.9 60.1
7 Masahiro Tanaka 653 709 805 152.0 95.9 56.1
8 Lance McCullers Jr. 661 606 352 309.0 254.1 54.9
9 Brad Boxberger 294 241 114 180.0 126.6 53.4
10 Jaime García 391 440 741 350.0 301.5 48.5

Strikeout Rate

Everybody Missed for Strikeout Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Justin Verlander 0.2813
0.1976
(71.0)
0.2029
(64.9)
0.1947
(72.3)
0.2006
(69.8)
Yordano Ventura 0.1765
0.2119
(33.0)
0.2118
(34.1)
0.2075
(30.7)
0.2164
(35.3)
Chris Sale 0.2569
0.3004
(44.0)
0.2844
(30.8)
0.3015
(46.4)
0.2994
(41.6)
Michael Pineda 0.2738
0.2173
(38.9)
0.2188
(36.7)
0.2197
(35.9)
0.2150
(41.9)
Félix Hernández 0.1863
0.2344
(34.8)
0.2423
(40.9)
0.2240
(29.0)
0.2449
(40.6)
John Lackey 0.2406
0.2034
(24.1)
0.1990
(26.4)
0.2026
(23.5)
0.2042
(24.7)
Clay Buchholz 0.1582
0.2009
(28.0)
0.2054
(31.6)
0.2021
(29.7)
0.1996
(26.4)
José Fernández 0.3433
0.2835
(40.4)
0.2628
(54.6)
0.2862
(37.2)
0.2808
(43.6)
Mike Fiers 0.1851
0.2171
(26.8)
0.2294
(36.8)
0.2212
(30.9)
0.2130
(22.7)
James Shields 0.1642
0.2213
(51.0)
0.2190
(50.3)
0.2135
(45.9)
0.2291
(56.1)

Individual Misses for Strikeout Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Marco Estrada 0.1795 0.2282 31.6
2 Kyle Hendricks 0.1852 0.2282 28.3
3 Hisashi Iwakuma 0.2006 0.1758 24.9
4 Kenta Maeda 0.2111 0.2500 24.3
5 Matt Harvey 0.2394 0.1891 22.2
6 Cole Hamels 0.2050 0.2358 22.0
7 Shelby Miller 0.1941 0.1522 21.6
8 Zack Greinke 0.2278 0.2009 21.3
9 Lance McCullers Jr. 0.2363 0.3011 21.1
10 Gerrit Cole 0.2292 0.1937 20.5

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Hisashi Iwakuma 0.2128 0.1758 36.3
2 Andrew Miller 0.3123 0.4473 35.4
3 Noah Syndergaard 0.2456 0.2930 30.5
4 Dellin Betances 0.3149 0.4214 29.9
5 Jordan Zimmermann 0.2043 0.1467 28.9
6 Max Scherzer 0.2771 0.3149 28.2
7 Kenley Jansen 0.3034 0.4143 26.2
8 Ken Giles 0.2610 0.3566 25.5
9 Masahiro Tanaka 0.2288 0.2050 24.4
10 Zack Greinke 0.2304 0.2009 24.0

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Marco Estrada 0.1740 0.2282 34.5
2 Kenta Maeda 0.2045 0.2500 27.9
3 Matt Harvey 0.2487 0.1891 26.6
4 Kyle Hendricks 0.1872 0.2282 25.6
5 Zack Greinke 0.2325 0.2009 25.5
6 Andrew Miller 0.3515 0.4473 24.5
7 Gerrit Cole 0.2325 0.1937 23.0
8 Ken Giles 0.2724 0.3566 22.2
9 Steve Cishek 0.2022 0.2946 22.1
10 Kenley Jansen 0.3224 0.4143 21.4

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Kyle Hendricks 0.1833 0.2282 30.9
2 Hisashi Iwakuma 0.2072 0.1758 29.1
3 Marco Estrada 0.1850 0.2282 28.8
4 Kevin Gausman 0.1898 0.2299 27.8
5 Cole Hamels 0.1998 0.2358 27.7
6 Chris Archer 0.2443 0.2741 22.5
7 Max Scherzer 0.2865 0.3149 22.5
8 Lance McCullers Jr. 0.2345 0.3011 22.3
9 Shelby Miller 0.1962 0.1522 21.8
10 Kenta Maeda 0.2177 0.2500 20.7

Most Unique Misses for Strikeout Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Noah Syndergaard 0.2456 0.2706 0.2930 30.5 13.0 17.5
2 Andrew Miller 0.3123 0.3772 0.4473 35.4 17.9 17.4
3 José Fernández 0.2628 0.2835 0.3433 54.6 40.4 14.2
4 Dellin Betances 0.3149 0.3616 0.4214 29.9 16.4 13.5
5 Jordan Zimmermann 0.2043 0.1771 0.1467 28.9 15.9 12.9
6 Edinson Volquez 0.1835 0.1711 0.1630 23.0 11.2 11.8
7 Kenley Jansen 0.3034 0.3509 0.4143 26.2 14.7 11.6
8 Adam Wainwright 0.2043 0.1922 0.1901 17.5 6.0 11.5
9 Hisashi Iwakuma 0.2128 0.2006 0.1758 36.3 24.9 11.4
10 Max Scherzer 0.2771 0.2911 0.3149 28.2 17.0 11.2

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Patrick Corbin 0.2090 0.2001 0.1869 20.1 12.8 7.3
2 Collin McHugh 0.1903 0.2007 0.2224 20.3 13.3 7.0
3 Kenley Jansen 0.3224 0.3509 0.4143 21.4 14.7 6.8
4 Jason Hammel 0.2189 0.2107 0.2081 12.0 5.3 6.7
5 Andrew Miller 0.3515 0.3772 0.4473 24.5 17.9 6.6
6 David Price 0.2506 0.2467 0.2397 16.6 11.3 5.2
7 Carlos Martinez 0.2329 0.2290 0.2151 19.7 15.3 4.5
8 Matt Harvey 0.2487 0.2394 0.1891 26.6 22.2 4.4
9 Danny Salazar 0.2439 0.2528 0.2757 14.7 10.4 4.3
10 Zack Greinke 0.2325 0.2278 0.2009 25.5 21.3 4.2

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Jeff Samardzija 0.2195 0.2080 0.2014 17.8 9.5 8.3
2 Kevin Gausman 0.1898 0.1983 0.2299 27.8 20.1 7.7
3 Félix Hernández 0.2449 0.2344 0.1863 40.6 34.8 5.8
4 Cole Hamels 0.1998 0.2050 0.2358 27.7 22.0 5.8
5 Max Scherzer 0.2865 0.2911 0.3149 22.5 17.0 5.5
6 James Shields 0.2291 0.2213 0.1642 56.1 51.0 5.1
7 David Robertson 0.3388 0.3188 0.2809 16.4 11.5 4.9
8 Aníbal Sánchez 0.2186 0.2099 0.2021 13.3 8.6 4.7
9 Chris Archer 0.2443 0.2482 0.2741 22.5 17.8 4.7
10 Hisashi Iwakuma 0.2072 0.2006 0.1758 29.1 24.9 4.2

Win Rate

Everybody Missed for Win Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Carlos Martinez 0.5161
0.3958
(112.4)
0.1837
(194.9)
0.3714
(123.2)
0.4194
(102.8)
Jon Lester 0.5938
0.4699
(113.4)
0.2895
(169.3)
0.4412
(127.4)
0.5000
(98.7)
Patrick Corbin 0.1389
0.3620
(143.3)
0.2414
(136.0)
0.3604
(150.0)
0.3636
(136.3)
Kyle Hendricks 0.5161
0.3344
(149.3)
0.2195
(152.8)
0.3825
(105.2)
0.2857
(194.2)
Aníbal Sánchez 0.2000
0.3967
(118.9)
0.2857
(118.4)
0.3768
(113.1)
0.4167
(124.5)
Michael Pineda 0.1875
0.4108
(154.7)
0.2632
(126.4)
0.3926
(149.4)
0.4286
(159.3)
Stephen Strasburg 0.6250
0.4513
(115.0)
0.2941
(143.1)
0.4195
(127.4)
0.4828
(103.2)
Corey Kluber 0.5625
0.4479
(114.6)
0.2821
(162.4)
0.4297
(120.7)
0.4667
(108.5)
José Fernández 0.5517
0.3821
(138.8)
0.2593
(148.1)
0.4209
(102.0)
0.3462
(173.8)
Max Scherzer 0.5882
0.4833
(111.4)
0.3590
(124.2)
0.4670
(116.1)
0.5000
(106.9)
Jason Hammel 0.5000
0.3412
(122.8)
0.2368
(118.7)
0.3749
(91.8)
0.3077
(154.0)

Individual Misses for Win Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Hisashi Iwakuma 0.3534 0.4848 125.5
2 Marcus Stroman 0.4265 0.2812 108.3
3 Chris Archer 0.4105 0.2727 101.3
4 Johnny Cueto 0.4688 0.5625 99.0
5 James Shields 0.3160 0.1818 95.0
6 Clay Buchholz 0.3947 0.2162 94.0
7 Cole Hamels 0.3817 0.4688 89.6
8 Shelby Miller 0.3534 0.1500 85.0
9 Sonny Gray 0.4063 0.2273 82.9

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 James Shields 0.2895 0.1818 163.8
2 Johnny Cueto 0.3077 0.5625 143.8
3 Chris Sale 0.2895 0.5312 136.2
4 Justin Verlander 0.2500 0.4706 116.5
5 Noah Syndergaard 0.2105 0.4516 111.2
6 Julio Teheran 0.2750 0.2333 101.0
7 Jake Arrieta 0.3659 0.5806 98.0
8 Cole Hamels 0.2632 0.4688 96.7
9 Sonny Gray 0.3000 0.2273 84.9

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Johnny Cueto 0.4081 0.5625 142.6
2 James Shields 0.3217 0.1818 108.8
3 Clay Buchholz 0.4085 0.2162 108.6
4 Drew Smyly 0.3795 0.2333 102.3
5 Marcus Stroman 0.4073 0.2812 101.3
6 Jake Arrieta 0.4623 0.5806 100.1
7 Hisashi Iwakuma 0.3734 0.4848 99.5
8 Chris Archer 0.3965 0.2727 98.8
9 Kenta Maeda 0.3719 0.5000 97.1

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Hisashi Iwakuma 0.3333 0.4848 152.0
2 Adam Wainwright 0.5652 0.3939 119.4
3 Marcus Stroman 0.4444 0.2812 113.6
4 Cole Hamels 0.3667 0.4688 112.3
5 Michael Wacha 0.4615 0.2593 104.2
6 Chris Archer 0.4242 0.2727 103.0
7 Jose Quintana 0.3226 0.4062 95.4
8 Julio Teheran 0.3871 0.2333 93.6
9 Sonny Gray 0.4375 0.2273 93.0

Most Unique Misses for Win Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Carlos Martinez 0.1837 0.3958 0.5161 194.9 112.4 82.4
2 James Shields 0.2895 0.3160 0.1818 163.8 95.0 68.8
3 Chris Sale 0.2895 0.4715 0.5312 136.2 71.1 65.1
4 Carlos Carrasco 0.2381 0.4640 0.4400 66.1 3.2 62.9
5 Noah Syndergaard 0.2105 0.3970 0.4516 111.2 54.5 56.7
6 Jon Lester 0.2895 0.4699 0.5938 169.3 113.4 55.9
7 Jeff Samardzija 0.2105 0.3793 0.3750 60.4 11.9 48.5
8 Edinson Volquez 0.2750 0.3287 0.2941 61.8 13.6 48.2
9 Corey Kluber 0.2821 0.4479 0.5625 162.4 114.6 47.8
10 Johnny Cueto 0.3077 0.4688 0.5625 143.8 99.0 44.8

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Johnny Cueto 0.4081 0.4688 0.5625 142.6 99.0 43.6
2 Drew Smyly 0.3795 0.3398 0.2333 102.3 64.8 37.5
3 Kevin Gausman 0.3625 0.3242 0.3000 41.6 4.2 37.4
4 Zack Greinke 0.4196 0.4683 0.5000 58.7 33.6 25.1
5 Kenta Maeda 0.3719 0.4133 0.5000 97.1 75.4 21.7
6 Jake Arrieta 0.4623 0.4986 0.5806 100.1 80.0 20.0
7 Carlos Carrasco 0.4122 0.4640 0.4400 21.2 3.2 18.0
8 Clay Buchholz 0.4085 0.3947 0.2162 108.6 94.0 14.6
9 Raisel Iglesias 0.3561 0.3226 0.0811 86.9 72.4 14.5
10 Félix Hernández 0.4003 0.4330 0.4400 31.0 16.8 14.1

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Adam Wainwright 0.5652 0.4775 0.3939 119.4 54.9 64.5
2 Kyle Hendricks 0.2857 0.3344 0.5161 194.2 149.3 45.0
3 Madison Bumgarner 0.5484 0.4925 0.4412 70.1 29.8 40.4
4 José Fernández 0.3462 0.3821 0.5517 173.8 138.8 35.1
5 Jose Quintana 0.3226 0.3510 0.4062 95.4 61.8 33.6
6 Mike Fiers 0.3103 0.3429 0.3548 54.1 22.2 32.0
7 Jason Hammel 0.3077 0.3412 0.5000 154.0 122.8 31.2
8 Taijuan Walker 0.2692 0.3112 0.3200 46.5 15.7 30.7
9 David Price 0.4516 0.4691 0.4857 61.2 33.6 27.7
10 Gerrit Cole 0.5333 0.4675 0.3333 85.9 58.4 27.4

Save Rate

Everybody Missed for Save Rate

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Francisco Rodríguez 0.7213
0.4523
(62.9)
0.4565
(64.4)
0.4877
(54.7)
0.0000
(157.1)
Aroldis Chapman 0.6102
0.3290
(62.1)
0.4286
(42.4)
0.3255
(63.0)
0.0000
(123.8)
Jeurys Familia 0.6538
0.5289
(39.7)
0.2909
(119.5)
0.5292
(39.7)
0.0000
(193.0)
Mark Melancon 0.6267
0.5210
(28.2)
0.4107
(60.8)
0.5385
(23.6)
0.0000
(155.0)
Kenley Jansen 0.6620
0.5273
(33.5)
0.4667
(51.4)
0.5385
(30.8)
0.0000
(152.9)
Roberto Osuna 0.5000
0.3123
(53.7)
0.2143
(85.0)
0.3062
(55.6)
0.0000
(128.8)
David Robertson 0.5968
0.4865
(29.1)
0.3830
(59.6)
0.4862
(29.3)
0.0000
(145.3)
Zack Britton 0.6812
0.5356
(36.6)
0.4130
(70.5)
0.5308
(38.0)
0.0000
(159.6)
AJ Ramos 0.5970
0.5002
(26.5)
0.1961
(114.0)
0.4985
(27.2)
0.0000
(151.3)

Individual Misses for Save Rate

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Ken Giles 0.5108 0.2174 84.3
2 Sean Doolittle 0.4921 0.0909 62.4
3 Raisel Iglesias 0.0000 0.1622 52.3
4 Drew Storen 0.2468 0.0526 44.6
5 Héctor Rondón 0.5404 0.3333 41.7
6 Shawn Tolleson 0.5275 0.2973 38.9
7 Brad Boxberger 0.3331 0.0000 38.1
8 Dellin Betances 0.0522 0.1644 33.1
9 J.J. Hoover 0.3948 0.0556 33.0
10 Trevor Rosenthal 0.4573 0.3111 29.1

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Wade Davis 0.1333 0.6000 83.8
2 Cody Allen 0.2778 0.4776 55.2
3 Santiago Casilla 0.3261 0.5000 44.2
4 Drew Storen 0.2340 0.0526 39.2
5 Steve Cishek 0.2609 0.4032 39.1
6 Brad Ziegler 0.2000 0.3188 37.0
7 Raisel Iglesias 0.0588 0.1622 36.6
8 Adam Wainwright 0.0476 0.0000 32.5
9 Noah Syndergaard 0.0526 0.0000 32.2
10 Brad Boxberger 0.2857 0.0000 31.5

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Ken Giles 0.5062 0.2174 82.8
2 Sean Doolittle 0.5046 0.0909 64.3
3 Raisel Iglesias 0.0000 0.1622 52.4
4 Drew Storen 0.2600 0.0526 47.5
5 Héctor Rondón 0.5385 0.3333 41.2
6 Shawn Tolleson 0.5292 0.2973 39.1
7 Brad Boxberger 0.3244 0.0000 37.1
8 Dellin Betances 0.0477 0.1644 34.6
9 J.J. Hoover 0.4000 0.0556 33.5
10 Trevor Rosenthal 0.4462 0.3111 26.8

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Cody Allen 0.0000 0.4776 112.2
2 Craig Kimbrel 0.0000 0.5439 108.1
3 Santiago Casilla 0.0000 0.5000 107.8
4 Wade Davis 0.0000 0.6000 96.3
5 Steve Cishek 0.0000 0.4032 90.4
6 Brad Ziegler 0.0000 0.3188 76.9
7 Jonathan Papelbon 0.0000 0.5135 70.0
8 Héctor Rondón 0.0000 0.3333 56.1
9 Trevor Rosenthal 0.0000 0.3111 50.9
10 David Price 0.0000 0.0000 50.1

Most Unique Misses for Save Rate

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 AJ Ramos 0.1961 0.5002 0.5970 114.0 26.5 87.5
2 Jeurys Familia 0.2909 0.5289 0.6538 119.5 39.7 79.8
3 Wade Davis 0.1333 0.4969 0.6000 83.8 17.9 65.9
4 Cody Allen 0.2778 0.5155 0.4776 55.2 10.3 44.9
5 Zack Britton 0.4130 0.5356 0.6812 70.5 36.6 33.8
6 Mark Melancon 0.4107 0.5210 0.6267 60.8 28.2 32.7
7 Adam Wainwright 0.0476 0.0000 0.0000 32.5 1.1 31.3
8 Roberto Osuna 0.2143 0.3123 0.5000 85.0 53.7 31.3
9 Noah Syndergaard 0.0526 0.0000 0.0000 32.2 1.0 31.2
10 Steven Matz 0.0667 0.0000 0.0000 31.4 0.7 30.7

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Jake McGee 0.3631 0.3463 0.2632 20.7 17.3 3.3
2 Drew Storen 0.2600 0.2468 0.0526 47.5 44.6 2.9
3 Cody Allen 0.5246 0.5155 0.4776 12.6 10.3 2.3
4 Brad Ziegler 0.3569 0.3490 0.3188 11.3 9.1 2.1
5 Andrew Miller 0.2600 0.2521 0.1714 24.6 22.6 2.0
6 Roberto Osuna 0.3062 0.3123 0.5000 55.6 53.7 1.9
7 Sean Doolittle 0.5046 0.4921 0.0909 64.3 62.4 1.9
8 Dellin Betances 0.0477 0.0522 0.1644 34.6 33.1 1.5
9 Steve Cishek 0.4615 0.4553 0.4032 15.3 13.8 1.5
10 Huston Street 0.5077 0.4936 0.3462 17.1 15.6 1.4

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Jeurys Familia 0.0000 0.5289 0.6538 193.0 39.7 153.3
2 Mark Melancon 0.0000 0.5210 0.6267 155.0 28.2 126.8
3 AJ Ramos 0.0000 0.5002 0.5970 151.3 26.5 124.8
4 Zack Britton 0.0000 0.5356 0.6812 159.6 36.6 123.0
5 Kenley Jansen 0.0000 0.5273 0.6620 152.9 33.5 119.5
6 David Robertson 0.0000 0.4865 0.5968 145.3 29.1 116.2
7 Craig Kimbrel 0.0000 0.5230 0.5439 108.1 4.3 103.8
8 Cody Allen 0.0000 0.5155 0.4776 112.2 10.3 101.8
9 Francisco Rodríguez 0.0000 0.4523 0.7213 157.1 62.9 94.2
10 Santiago Casilla 0.0000 0.4167 0.5000 107.8 19.8 88.0

ERA

Everybody Missed for ERA

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Shelby Miller 6.1485
3.8533
(852.0)
3.3768
(1072.0)
4.0580
(769.8)
3.6486
(934.4)
Jon Lester 2.4424
3.0763
(857.3)
3.2495
(993.6)
3.1673
(909.0)
2.9849
(804.9)
Kyle Hendricks 2.1316
3.6033
(1426.6)
3.6585
(1466.3)
3.5992
(1404.1)
3.6075
(1448.7)
Justin Verlander 3.0439
3.8382
(1117.4)
3.8351
(1112.8)
3.7886
(1049.1)
3.8884
(1185.8)
Aníbal Sánchez 5.8696
3.8996
(1019.9)
4.0388
(928.2)
3.8621
(1062.4)
3.9375
(977.6)
Zack Greinke 4.3676
2.8901
(690.0)
2.4723
(969.9)
2.9952
(637.2)
2.7850
(743.1)
Noah Syndergaard 2.5971
3.1152
(715.2)
3.4964
(997.3)
3.1429
(716.4)
3.0872
(713.3)
Sonny Gray 5.6923
3.4690
(920.3)
3.0687
(1128.3)
3.7406
(793.4)
3.1991
(1046.7)
James Shields 5.8459
3.6968
(1402.3)
3.5880
(1493.3)
3.8549
(1293.7)
3.5386
(1511.3)
J.J. Hoover 13.5000
3.9146
(886.8)
3.6909
(908.7)
3.9925
(881.8)
3.8369
(891.9)

Individual Misses for ERA

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Marco Estrada 4.2276 3.4773 862.9
2 Jose Quintana 3.7118 3.2019 797.6
3 Masahiro Tanaka 3.5916 3.0651 780.5
4 Patrick Corbin 3.5915 5.1456 778.8
5 Cole Hamels 3.7519 3.3189 742.9
6 Julio Teheran 3.7317 3.2074 733.3
7 Adam Wainwright 3.3203 4.6208 726.2
8 Francisco Liriano 3.2707 4.6933 716.0
9 Drew Smyly 3.4650 4.8764 714.6
10 Dallas Keuchel 3.1641 4.5536 663.4

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Adam Wainwright 2.8247 4.6208 1147.6
2 Edinson Volquez 3.7287 5.3715 1024.9
3 Drew Smyly 3.3439 4.8764 805.4
4 Michael Wacha 3.4087 5.0870 749.7
5 Jaime García 3.2143 4.6660 748.8
6 Patrick Corbin 3.6451 5.1456 742.6
7 Madison Bumgarner 3.0745 2.7397 707.7
8 Carlos Martinez 3.4664 3.0410 701.1
9 Zack Britton 2.8550 0.5373 700.8
10 Dallas Keuchel 3.1304 4.5536 688.3

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Marco Estrada 4.3968 3.4773 966.4
2 Patrick Corbin 3.4781 5.1456 876.6
3 Drew Smyly 3.2910 4.8764 862.2
4 Michael Pineda 3.3609 4.8159 784.7
5 Julio Teheran 3.8086 3.2074 771.8
6 Dallas Keuchel 3.0383 4.5536 769.8
7 Cole Hamels 3.8088 3.3189 769.1
8 Jose Quintana 3.6919 3.2019 759.2
9 Carlos Martinez 3.4684 3.0410 683.2
10 Francisco Liriano 3.3480 4.6933 678.5

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Masahiro Tanaka 3.8245 3.0651 988.6
2 Adam Wainwright 3.1154 4.6208 878.1
3 Jose Quintana 3.7321 3.2019 836.0
4 Marco Estrada 4.0614 3.4773 761.2
5 Kevin Gausman 4.1357 3.6067 755.2
6 Francisco Liriano 3.1924 4.6933 754.5
7 Edinson Volquez 4.0551 5.3715 723.1
8 Cole Hamels 3.6943 3.3189 715.7
9 Julio Teheran 3.6548 3.2074 694.4
10 Zack Britton 2.7931 0.5373 692.0

Most Unique Misses for ERA

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Jeff Samardzija 4.1214 3.3673 3.8066 626.8 3.2 623.6
2 Adam Wainwright 2.8247 3.3203 4.6208 1147.6 726.2 421.4
3 Edinson Volquez 3.7287 4.1585 5.3715 1024.9 656.7 368.3
4 Max Scherzer 3.0987 2.6953 2.9562 526.5 164.4 362.1
5 Kenta Maeda 3.8361 3.3744 3.4839 568.1 238.9 329.2
6 Madison Bumgarner 3.0745 2.7210 2.7397 707.7 387.0 320.7
7 Carlos Carrasco 3.5673 3.0691 3.3212 411.7 114.4 297.2
8 Noah Syndergaard 3.4964 3.1152 2.5971 997.3 715.2 282.2
9 Zack Greinke 2.4723 2.8901 4.3676 969.9 690.0 280.0
10 Jordan Zimmermann 3.3943 3.9213 4.8703 465.6 227.6 238.0

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Michael Pineda 3.3609 3.6063 4.8159 784.7 579.5 205.2
2 David Price 3.0098 3.1797 3.9913 536.8 350.4 186.3
3 Mike Fiers 3.7150 3.9389 4.4822 253.5 72.5 180.9
4 Drew Smyly 3.2910 3.4650 4.8764 862.2 714.6 147.6
5 Jake Arrieta 2.9511 2.7554 3.1014 212.1 77.3 134.9
6 Chris Sale 2.7910 2.8893 3.3353 115.4 2.6 112.8
7 Aaron Nola 3.7588 3.9607 4.7838 293.6 183.5 110.1
8 John Lackey 3.6819 3.5128 3.3451 563.9 456.9 107.0
9 Dallas Keuchel 3.0383 3.1641 4.5536 769.8 663.4 106.4
10 Hisashi Iwakuma 3.5181 3.6180 4.1156 150.8 45.5 105.3

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Masahiro Tanaka 3.8245 3.5916 3.0651 988.6 780.5 208.1
2 Taijuan Walker 4.3349 4.0473 4.2208 333.9 154.5 179.4
3 Adam Wainwright 3.1154 3.3203 4.6208 878.1 726.2 151.9
4 Sonny Gray 3.1991 3.4690 5.6923 1046.7 920.3 126.4
5 Kevin Gausman 4.1357 4.0071 3.6067 755.2 638.5 116.7
6 Chris Sale 2.9898 2.8893 3.3353 111.7 2.6 109.1
7 James Shields 3.5386 3.6968 5.8459 1511.3 1402.3 109.0
8 Gio Gonzalez 3.4303 3.5824 4.5677 511.5 414.7 96.8
9 Shelby Miller 3.6486 3.8533 6.1485 934.4 852.0 82.4
10 Jason Hammel 3.9284 3.8428 3.8340 389.7 312.8 76.9

WHIP

Everybody Missed for WHIP

Player Actual Aggregate Marcel Steamer ZiPS
Shelby Miller 1.6733
1.2905
(144.6)
1.2561
(164.6)
1.3053
(139.4)
1.2757
(149.9)
Francisco Liriano 1.4847
1.2295
(136.6)
1.2478
(129.7)
1.2265
(141.3)
1.2325
(132.0)
Jon Lester 1.0164
1.1122
(130.7)
1.1707
(170.1)
1.1189
(133.2)
1.1055
(127.9)
Matt Harvey 1.4676
1.0817
(127.6)
1.0799
(132.0)
1.0832
(128.4)
1.0802
(126.9)
Julio Teheran 1.0532
1.2316
(187.1)
1.2259
(176.0)
1.2450
(194.5)
1.2183
(179.4)
Patrick Corbin 1.5610
1.2099
(198.2)
1.2440
(180.6)
1.1922
(213.1)
1.2280
(183.2)
Kyle Hendricks 0.9789
1.2178
(228.9)
1.1882
(200.2)
1.2205
(228.3)
1.2150
(229.3)
Justin Verlander 1.0015
1.2456
(282.1)
1.2715
(297.5)
1.2376
(271.9)
1.2536
(292.3)
John Lackey 1.0566
1.1792
(142.8)
1.2357
(178.4)
1.2001
(155.8)
1.1585
(129.8)
Clayton Kershaw 0.7248
0.9302
(148.9)
0.9529
(156.4)
0.9442
(154.6)
0.9163
(143.1)
Adam Wainwright 1.4044
1.1689
(141.5)
1.1147
(195.0)
1.1970
(120.7)
1.1410
(162.4)
James Shields 1.5963
1.2340
(241.6)
1.2680
(221.0)
1.2562
(226.2)
1.2118
(257.1)

Individual Misses for WHIP

Aggregate

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Marco Estrada 1.2497 1.1193 143.7
2 Trevor Rosenthal 1.1540 1.9091 135.3
3 Max Scherzer 1.0363 0.9679 123.4
4 Jose Quintana 1.2367 1.1635 118.6
5 Gerrit Cole 1.1488 1.4397 112.6
6 Michael Pineda 1.1343 1.3491 110.7
7 Edinson Volquez 1.3512 1.5475 109.1
8 Michael Wacha 1.2310 1.4783 108.4

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Edinson Volquez 1.3167 1.5475 146.2
2 Sonny Gray 1.1561 1.4957 144.9
3 Hisashi Iwakuma 1.0984 1.3266 141.1
4 Max Scherzer 1.0586 0.9679 135.4
5 Jose Quintana 1.2567 1.1635 127.8
6 Jaime García 1.1491 1.3748 123.2
7 Aníbal Sánchez 1.2190 1.4609 121.9
8 Andrew Miller 1.0697 0.6861 121.8

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Marco Estrada 1.2990 1.1193 176.8
2 Trevor Rosenthal 1.1429 1.9091 138.2
3 Michael Pineda 1.1071 1.3491 133.9
4 Edinson Volquez 1.3452 1.5475 117.3
5 Gerrit Cole 1.1503 1.4397 113.6
6 Aníbal Sánchez 1.2336 1.4609 108.5
7 Michael Wacha 1.2347 1.4783 108.3
8 Andrew Miller 1.0110 0.6861 107.2

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Actual Error
1 Max Scherzer 1.0691 0.9679 155.9
2 Jose Quintana 1.2543 1.1635 136.0
3 Trevor Rosenthal 1.1652 1.9091 132.4
4 Sonny Gray 1.1801 1.4957 126.1
5 Hisashi Iwakuma 1.1106 1.3266 120.7
6 Gerrit Cole 1.1474 1.4397 111.6
7 Marco Estrada 1.2013 1.1193 111.1
8 Michael Wacha 1.2273 1.4783 108.7

Most Unique Misses for WHIP

Players where this system’s error exceeded Aggregate’s error by the largest margin.

Marcel

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Jeff Samardzija 1.2354 1.1496 1.2000 78.6 14.9 63.7
2 Jaime García 1.1491 1.2129 1.3748 123.2 69.3 53.9
3 Kenta Maeda 1.2449 1.1610 1.1385 118.7 65.0 53.7
4 Adam Wainwright 1.1147 1.1689 1.4044 195.0 141.5 53.5
5 Chris Sale 1.0984 1.0328 1.0368 109.8 58.4 51.5
6 Sonny Gray 1.1561 1.2316 1.4957 144.9 101.2 43.7
7 Stephen Strasburg 1.1438 1.0645 1.1038 59.5 17.3 42.1
8 Hisashi Iwakuma 1.0984 1.1372 1.3266 141.1 101.2 39.9
9 Carlos Martinez 1.3095 1.2514 1.2235 117.6 77.8 39.8
10 Jon Lester 1.1707 1.1122 1.0164 170.1 130.7 39.4

Steamer

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Marco Estrada 1.2990 1.2497 1.1193 176.8 143.7 33.1
2 David Price 1.0736 1.1025 1.2043 62.7 31.8 30.8
3 Michael Pineda 1.1071 1.1343 1.3491 133.9 110.7 23.2
4 Mike Leake 1.3092 1.2772 1.3189 41.8 20.2 21.6
5 Jake Arrieta 1.1059 1.0762 1.0845 68.6 47.8 20.9
6 Mike Fiers 1.2087 1.2321 1.3577 60.9 41.5 19.4
7 Johnny Cueto 1.1368 1.1118 1.0926 96.1 77.2 18.9
8 Mark Melancon 1.1582 1.0856 0.8972 88.0 69.3 18.6
9 Chris Archer 1.1541 1.1783 1.2417 19.3 4.2 15.1
10 Patrick Corbin 1.1922 1.2099 1.5610 213.1 198.2 14.8

ZiPS

Rank Player Proj Agg Actual Error Agg Err Unique
1 Kevin Gausman 1.3392 1.2935 1.2801 98.9 61.9 37.1
2 Max Scherzer 1.0691 1.0363 0.9679 155.9 123.4 32.5
3 Sonny Gray 1.1801 1.2316 1.4957 126.1 101.2 24.9
4 Chris Archer 1.2031 1.1783 1.2417 28.1 4.2 23.9
5 Chris Sale 1.0528 1.0328 1.0368 79.5 58.4 21.2
6 Adam Wainwright 1.1410 1.1689 1.4044 162.4 141.5 20.8
7 Hisashi Iwakuma 1.1106 1.1372 1.3266 120.7 101.2 19.5
8 Jose Quintana 1.2543 1.2367 1.1635 136.0 118.6 17.4
9 Félix Hernández 1.1082 1.1373 1.3239 94.4 77.4 16.9
10 Jeurys Familia 1.0649 1.1195 1.2103 23.7 7.2 16.5